A map developed by the Spanish Alianza Contra el Borrado de las Mujeres – Alliance Against the Erasure of Women - collects and locates over a hundred cases in which the application of the law on self-determination of anagraphic sex, the so-called Ley Trans, It would have had controversial effects on the functioning of laws against male violence, on equality policies and on the protection of spaces reserved for women.
Long before the law was approved, feminist organizations had already reported the risk of conflict between legal sex self-determination And protections based on the legal category of sex. The documented cases would show how, in some situations, the change of registry has prevented the application of the law against violence against women, transferring proceedings from specialized courts to ordinary courts, with the consequent loss of specific protections for victims.
The map shows episodes in which Men convicted or investigated for violence against partners or ex-partners were not tried under the violence legislation male because the attacks occurred after the registered sex was changed. In other cases, uncertainty about judicial jurisdiction would have slowed proceedings, impacting the safety of the victims.
The report also points out a possible opportunistic use of the law in different areas: from access to public competitions with differentiated physical evidence, it is particularly highlighted the high number of requests for change of anagraphic sex coming from members of armed forces, police, firefighters, to the occupation of reserved quotas to women on the electoral lists, up to the requests for child custody.
A relevant chapter concerns access to reserved spaces to women, as changing rooms in workplaces, sports facilities and prisons Female. The map includes cases reported by workers, families, and associations, as well as incidents involving inmates convicted of sexual or violent crimes who, after changing their registered sex, requested transfer to women's prisons. The dossier emphasizes that changing registered sex does not require a criminal background check.
The document also criticizes the role of the media, accused of systematically confusing sex and gender in the reporting of these cases, contributing – according to the authors – to distort crime statistics and to obscure male responsibility in crimes such as rape and femicide.
Finally, a report is made lack of institutional transparency. In response to official requests for access to documents, the Ministry of the Presidency, Justice, and Parliamentary Relations reportedly declared that it did not have aggregate data on the number, geographical distribution, and gender of applicants, rejected cases, or potential fraud. This information gap, according to the Alliance, is not accidental but rather indicates a desire not to disclose the law's actual effects.
The map, the promoters conclude, questions official statements about the lack of negative impact of the law on women's rights and calls for a public debate based on verifiable data.
Translation and adaptation by Efferre
Here you can find the original dossier and consult the map
This article is produced through voluntary work.
Much of the news you read here you won't find in any other media.
If you think our work is useful, thank you if you can support us.
Even the smallest contribution is precious!

