With an ordinance - n. 8325/ 2020-la Court of Cassation asks again Constitutional Court that a little girl - or born - or from a rented womb could be registered in the registry as the daughter of two fathers, the “biological” father and the other defined as “intentional” father. The United Sections of the Supreme Court had already clearly ruled against this possibility, but surprisingly the First Section intended to reopen the issue and now the ruling of the Constitutional Court is awaited, scheduled for January 27. Court to which we of Italian Network against the Rented Womb we addressed the following letter.
“Sentence no. 12193/2019 of the United Sections of the Court of Cassation has offered legal consistency to what we women of the Italian Network against Uterus for Rent have always supported: that is, thatThe first right, interest and need of each child who is born is not to be torn away from the mother who gave birth to her, as well as knowing that it was from her that he came into the world.
A few months before the sentence we had in fact turned to the Mayor, Council and City Council of Milan to ask them to decide to stop the automatic transcriptions - which were now becoming consolidated as usual - of foreign birth certificates of girls and boys born from rented wombs. Birth records in which the truth about the origins of creatures was replaced and "surrogated" by claim to be indicated as fathers or mothers in the absence of genetic link, on the basis of simple "intention" - as well as the fact of having paid for this supposed "right" - thus perfecting the cancellation of the mother provided for by the subrogation contracts.
We asked for that only the biological parent was indicated in the birth certificate, possibly suggesting the institution of adoption in particular cases by the father's partner as a possible way to guarantee emotional continuity. We were listened to. The Municipality of Milan blocked the transcriptions well before sentence 12193/2019 which clearly indicated this path.
We were therefore surprised to learn of ordinance no. 8325 of 2020 with which, a few months after that sentence, the same Supreme Court (first section) reopens the question again. The ordinance raises the question of the constitutionality of the art. 12, paragraph 6, of law no. 40 of 2004 (the article of law that prohibits and sanctions the use of a rented uterus in Italy), of the articles. 18 of Presidential Decree 396 of 2000 and 64, paragraph 1, letter. g, and law no. 218 of 1995 in the part in which they do not allow that the inclusion of the so-called "intending parent" is recognized in the civil status certificate of a minor born from a rented womb. According to the ordinance, the ruling of the United Sections would be in irreconcilable conflict with the opinion expressed on the matter by the Grand Chamber of the European Court.
It is neither our task nor our intention to delve into the formalities of legal issues which we believe we can identify speciousness. The substance lies in the repeated attempt to bring back through the window what we thought had been definitively kicked out through the door: the recognition of full parenthood for those who are not parents is based on a supposed economically acquired "right", where money can do everything, also violating the dignity of a woman who is clearly in a state of need (of more than one, also considering the suppliers of oocytes) and jeopardizing the destiny of a creature on whom such a deep and incurable wound is inflicted: where would the parental love, when it is your desire to count more than everything and everyone?
Allow the full transcription at the registry office of birth certificates made abroad for those born and those born from rented wombs (not to mention the possibility of judging the ban on surrogacy expressed by law 40 to be unconstitutional) it would open the doors to a practice of which the Constitutional Court itself has reiterated the illegitimacy, stating that “It offends the dignity of women in an intolerable way and profoundly undermines human relationships." (ruling 272/2017).
We therefore express the hope that the Constitutional Court will stick to what has already been clearly expressed and reiterated and will reject in its entirety what is proposed by order 8325/2020 of the Cassation".
Italian Network against the Rented Womb.
This article is produced through voluntary work.
Much of the news you read here you won't find in any other media.
If you think our work is useful, thank you if you can support us.
Even the smallest contribution is precious!

