12 March 2021

Spain: left-wing women rebel -finally- against the Podemos transcult and break with the party and Ley Trans

Please be aware that the translation of contents, although automatic, has a cost to Feminist Post but is provided to you without any charge. Please consider making a contribution via the "Support us" page if you intend to use our translation service intensively.
The contents of this site are translated using automatic translation systems without the intervention of professional translators.
Translations are provided for the sole purpose of facilitating reading by international visitors.
Share this article

While the Italian left, including women, silently suffers Cirinnismo and Boldrinismo and its transcult (the news of an appeal by the European Commission has just International House of Women in Rome in support of Monica Cirinnà as mayor, see here), militants of the Spanish left, Podemos and Izquierda Unida, revolt en masse against the Ley Trans (see here) proposed by their own party's Igualdad minister, Irene Montero, the local Cirinnà (the Psoe has always opposed the law), denouncing the "imposition" of ideas "diametrically opposed to women's interests". without any internal debate and in solidarity with the feminist front that is gathered in Contra Borrado. We recall that The Ley Trans intends to introduce gender self-certification (self-id) in Spain. and that in the same spirit in Italy the Zan law against homobi-transphobiawhich has already been approved in the Chamber of Deputies with the unanimous support of the centre-left (including women). keeps gender identity at the centre, ignoring arguments to the contrary put forward by feminism (you can read them here): All the world is a country. Let the militants of the Spanish left set an example for the Italian ones.

Activists from Podemos and Izquierda Unida signed two documents critical of the Ley Trans proposed by the Ministry of Equality (headed by Irene Montero, Podemos, ndr) in which they denounce the fact that the project has not been subjected to internal debate and requires concepts and ideas 'diametrically opposed to women's interests'.

The Podemos document, signed by some 1,700 exponents, militants and members of the purple formation, declares 'concern' about the Ley Trans, the text of which 'has not been discussed in any body of the party, nor with the base'. As they denounce, at government level Podemos 'has imposed a unique and unenforceable position', which is why a 'public and internal' debate is 'demanded', and to consider 'the positions of practitioners from different disciplines' dealing with the issue.

"To say that 'rights are not up for discussion' is a form of authoritarianism that is unacceptable in any democratic organisation that we cannot share or allow," says the text entitled "In Podemos there are also feminists".


Among the first signatories were the head of Feminism of Podemos in Ponferrada, María Páramo; the head of Feminism of Podemos in Avila, Lucía Spínola, city councillors such as Colmenarejo (Madrid), Alberic (Valencia) or Pasaia (Guipúzcoa) or the exponent of the State Feminism Circle and party militant Mar Benavent. Benavent complained that apart from no debate, the draft of the Ley Trans had seen the light "without the necessary legal guarantees", so as not to have to deal with the rights of other categories.

This law 'destroys historical feminist claims', said Benavent in an interview with Onda Cero, and added that the moment one raises 'any objection or doubt' about it, one is branded as 'transphobic'.When you are accused of transphobia, the dialogue is over," he complained.

The document explains that "many feminists' have joined Podemos 'with the firm hope of seeing our historical demands represented'. as well as the protection of our rights. Which is well known "oppression" is "based on the sex with which we come into the world, observable and verifiable biological reality that we cannot ignore or distort if our intention is really to achieve women's liberation'.

"We know that gender is a social construction that functions as the tool that allows, supports and perpetuates this oppression, and that only its abolition will allow us to break with the patriarchal structure that keeps us subordinate and vulnerable" continues the Podemos women's document. So theories that 'go so far as to contradict what has been affirmed in more than three centuries of feminist struggle not only have nothing to do with the positions and objectives of our agenda, but slow down and weaken our progress'.

"We are clear that the irruption of queer theories into our spaces constitutes a clear manoeuvre of entrism that aims to disarticulate our struggle, depoliticising and weakening our collective strength by making the magical thinking and the purest individualism as weapons to manipulate reality at will,' the statement continues, saying that one cannot afford 'to question that it is we, the women, who constitute the political subject of Feminism'.

The petitioners call for the feminist movement not to become "a bag in which to keep things that have nothing to do with its raison d'être and that clash head-on with its objectives" and to be "firm and decisive" in the face of situations such as those denounced.


Regarding childhood, the petitioners consider it "unacceptable" that attempts are being made to "disguise as protection the very real mistreatment" that is based on the "postulates supported by queer irrationality" defended by the Minister for Equality.

"Directing minors towards hormonal and surgical proceduresPreventing the free development of their personality, perpetuating sexist stereotypes is something we cannot tolerate,' the manifesto states in relation to children.

Therefore, the signatories of the document demand that the ministry led by Irene Montero 'take into consideration' the position 'expressed both by the many feminist thinkers and by numerous organisations' as they regret, their requests for a meeting were 'ignored', which they consider 'disrespectful and irresponsible'.


The militants of Izquierda Unida also published a manifesto in very similar terms.
Under the title "Retake Feminism'. party activists opposed to the 'ideological turn that institutional policies are taking on feminist issues". "As a coalition we suffered first the disappearance of the Women's Area, then the expulsion of the Feminist Party and, more recently, the proposed 'gender self-identification' law known as Ley Trans," the text explains.

With regard to the Ley Trans, it complains that the project has been presented publicly in a "very superficial way", "without a thorough debate", without taking into account all the social actors or going into the legal issues in depth.

"The bill wielded by the Igualdad minister, which we consider a symbol of the entry of these neoliberal policies into the political sphere of the left, not only does not improve the defence of the rights of transgender people, but on the contrary favours the "erasure" of these people, of LGB people and of women in general". warn the petitioners.

It is also stated that the historical abolitionist agenda of the feminist movement, covering prostitution, pornography, surrogacy and gender, has shifted to defending 'certain postulates of neoliberal normative ideology and gender' which 'have nothing to do' with those of Izquierda Unida and the coalitions to which it belongs.

The manifesto calls for 'deep and honest' reflection and the involvement of 'all parties' in the debate. The signatories close their statement by opposing "these new policies that take over the feminist struggle and disarticulate it".


When asked about these documents, Podemos said it had voted 'on numerous occasions' internally in support of human rights, which include the rights of trans people.
This is how the co-spokesperson of the Purple Formation, Isa Serra, describes the text signed by the members of her own party. Although, she says, she "respects the opinion of these women" in the "internal congresses" and in the electoral programme they voted in this way. "I believe that on numerous occasions the party as a whole has voted in favour of human rights," he said. "Our election manifesto is clear on that, and the rights of trans people are human rights."

(the original article heretranslation by Cecilia Salas)

Much of the news published by Feminist Post you will not read elsewhere. That is why it is important to support us, even with a small contribution: Feminist Post is produced solely by the voluntary work of many people and has no funding.
If you think our work can be useful for your life, we will be grateful for even the smallest contribution.

You can give us your contribution by clicking here: Patreon - Feminist Post
   - or -
Obligatory reason: FEMINIST POST
IBAN: IT80C0200812914000104838541
You might also be interested in
16 January 2023
Italian psychoanalysts: stop puberty blockers
The Italian Psychoanalytic Society criticises puberty blockers for children: dangerous and experimental treatment. And joins gender critical feminists and parents in calling for scientific data and a public debate on the best treatment for children suffering from gender dysphoria
For years we gender critical feminists have been fighting against the scandal of the medicalisation of children in the name of gender identity. And for years we have been branded as fascists, reactionaries, bigots. Today at last an accredited Italian scientific society, the Italian Psychoanalytic Society (SPI), is taking a stand, joining us in raising a cry of alarm: the use of puberty blockers is an experimental treatment that has no solid scientific basis, and causes serious side effects. Above all, in most cases dysphoria [...]
Read now
29 December 2022
2022, the year the West erased women
According to Ayaan Hirsi Ali, radical critic of Islam, subjugating fundamentalists and Western transactivist progressivism are de facto allies: both endanger women and threaten post-Enlightenment ideals
If 2022 was the year of the 'woman', it was a story with two different final chapters: one hopeful, the other less so. The first is set in a faraway country, where an archaic and theocratic regime threatens to be overthrown by women throwing off their hijabs and demanding their emancipation. The second takes place in a more familiar setting but in an unfamiliar language: a West where the very word 'woman' no longer has any [...]
Read now
27 December 2022
The global abolition of sex
The law just passed in Scotland replacing sex with free choice of gender. The one being passed in Spain. And Germany's project. In her article in Newsweek, Kara Dansky also warns the United States about self-id. But from Great Britain, Sweden and Finland come signals in stark contrast: the game is still to be played.
22 December was a black day for gender critical feminism: in spite of lively protests outside Parliament, Scotland passed the law allowing gender self-identification or self-id -without exception for sex offenders who will be able to freely access women's spaces by identifying themselves as women. Also in Spain, the Ley Trans, which has a very similar structure, has passed the first step in the lower house and is on its way to final approval in the coming weeks [...].
Read now
13 December 2022
The magic of JK Rowling! Who in trans-Scotland opens an anti-violence centre FOR ONLY WOMEN
In Edinburgh there was not a single anti-violence shelter that was not also accessible to men claiming to be women. And the main centre is run by a transsexual. Surprisingly, the writer founds and finances a space strictly for women only. Challenging Premier Nicola Sturgeon's transgender policies. And meeting the real needs of victims of violence
We have told you several times about JK Rowling's commitment to women's rights in Scotland, where Prime Minister Nicola Sturgeon is pushing for the passage of a law that would introduce a 'super self-ID' (see here), a very liberal gender identity. Last year, even before the bill was debated, the appointment of a transgender man, Mridul Wadhwa, as chief executive of Edinburgh's leading anti-violence shelter, which of course would also welcome men who 'identify as women' in what [...]
Read now
5 October 2022
The Iranians are fighting for us too
Women in Iran are oppressed, violated and killed precisely because of their bodies as women. And their revolt could free everyone and everyone. Is'the woke West of'gender identity and 'freedom of the veil' ready to understand and support this revolution that blows for us too? Woman, life, freedom
In the uncertain and ever-changing geopolitical order of our time, in the midst of a global political agenda that from right to left forgets women, betraying, albeit in different ways, female exclusivity and the richness of sexual difference, the struggle of Iranian women has something epic, something moving. The killing of Mahsa Amini shows how the issue of the 'veil as freedom' is the quintessence of intellectual dishonesty, of logical fallacy, of an age-old lie. To 22-year-old Mahsa, the desire to 'feel the [...]
Read now
27 September 2022
Feminism and the Right
In response to Julie Bindel, who considers the wall erected by the transactivist left but also the risks of an alliance with the right: in Italy, the historical novelty -a right-wing woman premier, Giorgia Meloni- further complicates the picture. What to do then? What is happening in Spain over the horrible Ley Trans perhaps points to a good way forward for everyone
Julie Bindel and Harvey Jeni take the bull by the horns: given that for too long there has been no possibility of dialogue with the left, can radical and gender-critical feminism look to the right without taking risks? This is a theme that we in Italy are well aware of and that agitated the entire election campaign that ended with the landslide victory of a right-wing woman, Giorgia Meloni, who has never declared herself a feminist. The fact that today the right in Italy is [...]
Read now
1 2 3 ... 19