29 January 2021

Constitutional Court: a law is needed on the recognition of surrogate children

Please be aware that the translation of contents, although automatic, has a cost to Feminist Post but is provided to you without any charge. Please consider making a contribution via the "Support us" page if you intend to use our translation service intensively.
The contents of this site are translated using automatic translation systems without the intervention of professional translators.
Translations are provided for the sole purpose of facilitating reading by international visitors.
Share this article

In a ruling handed down yesterday, the Constitutional Court called on the Italian Parliament to legislate on the issue of recognition of children born from surrogacy, considering that "without prejudice to the criminal prohibition of surrogacy, the current legal framework does not ensure full protection of the interests of the child born through surrogacy technique"This was announced by the Court's press office in anticipation of the filing.

In short: the order - no. 8325/2020 - of the Court of Cassation had posed the Constitutional Court with the problem of the 'inability' of the Court of Justice to decide whether or not to apply the law.impossibility of registering as both 'fathers' of the child born of surrogacy carried out abroad (indeed, the Supreme Court in United Sections had already clearly spoken out against this possibilitybut surprisingly, the First Chamber wanted to reopen the question).

Put in a more technical wayThe order raised the question of the constitutionality of Article 12(6) of Law no. 40 of 2004 (the article of law prohibiting and sanctioning the use of surrogate wombs in Italy), of Article 18 of Presidential Decree no. 396 of 2000 and of Article 64(1)(b) of Law no. 40 of 2004. gand Law No 218 of 1995 in so far as do not allow that the inclusion of the so-called 'intended parent' be recognised in the civil status certificate of a child born of a surrogate mother. According to the order, the judgment of the United Sections is in irreconcilable conflict with the opinion expressed on this matter by the Grand Chamber of the European Court.

The Constitutional Court declared the question "inadmissible", but recognised the existence of the problem and referred it back to the legislator.

The "problem", as we were saying, had already been addressed and resolved by the Court of Cassation itself in judgment no. 12193/2019 in Sezioni Unite, which held that only the biological father of the child born of a surrogate mother could be registered at the civil register, while his (or her) partner, lacking any biological ties with the creature, could possibly have recourse to the institution of theadoption in special cases. That ruling considered the child's right to emotional continuity, but gave priority to his or her right to know the truth about their origins, while rejecting the right of the so-called 'intended parent' to be registered at the registry on the basis of his or her mere participation in a 'parental project' guaranteed by a commercial contract with an associated payment. Children are not paid for, parental status is not for sale (for those who can afford it) and the mothers we are all born to are not erased with a bank transfer.

As written in the letter sent to the Constitutional Court by our Italian Network against Utero in Rent "the first right, interest and need of every person who is born is not to be torn away from the mother who gave birth to him or her, and to know that it was from her that he or she came into the world.". 

Unfortunately, the Court of Justice, which in its judgment 272/2017 had also reiterated the prohibition on the use of surrogacy, a practice which, as it is written, is not permitted. "intolerably offends the dignity of women and deeply undermines human relations'.in its new pronouncement invites the legislator to examine the issue and therefore seems to open up the possibility of full transcription to the registry birth certificates issued abroad for births and births through 'surrogacy'.

If the law were to allow the full transcription of those birth certificates, it would in fact be a semi-recognition of the legitimacy of the practice despite its stigmatisation, removing a significant obstacle for the benefit of those who use it.

In a completely different direction is the A bill currently being considered by the House Judiciary Committee that proposes making it a punishable offence to use surrogacy even if carried out abroad.

But what strikes like a punch in the stomach is that in the Court's judgment, the practice is referred to as an technique. The surrogate mother uses the techniques of assisted fertilisation - ovarian stimulation, egg retrieval, in vitro fertilisation, implantation in the uterus and so on - but cannot in any way be called a technique in itself. The surrogate motherhood is slavery, it is material and spiritual poverty, it is the buying and selling of the human being, it is the violation of fundamental rights, it is the erasure of the mother, it is the painful detachment of the creature from those who gave birth to it, it is the claim that desires become rights and that money is the sole measure of all other values. All this cannot, inhumanly, be called a technique.

Marina Terragni

  


Much of the news published by Feminist Post you will not read elsewhere. That is why it is important to support us, even with a small contribution: Feminist Post is produced solely by the voluntary work of many people and has no funding.
If you think our work can be useful for your life, we will be grateful for even the smallest contribution.

You can give us your contribution by clicking here: Patreon - Feminist Post
   - or -
You can send to: ASSOCIAZIONE CULTURALE BLU BRAMANTE
Obligatory reason: FEMINIST POST
IBAN: IT80C0200812914000104838541
You might also be interested in
21 October 2022
Women-containers: pro-life and pro-utero for hire see eye to eye
For one and the other, the female body must make itself available to 'produce' the unborn child by renouncing the possibility of choice once pregnancy has begun. But a new life only really begins when there is a maternal yes: a fact that is unattainable and unattainable by law. Otherwise the only possibility is compulsion.
At least three things can be said about the bill filed by Maurizio Gasparri to amend Article 1 of the Civil Code and introduce into our legal system the recognition of the legal capacity of the conceived 'with the intention of preventing voluntary abortion in any form, whether legal or clandestine'. The first: it is highly unlikely that the bill will reach parliamentary halls. The immediate consequence of its approval would be the substantial inapplicability of law 194 because abortion would in fact be tantamount to murder. None of the majority forces [...]
Read now
4 October 2022
US, gay couple sues: surrogacy is a 'right', must be paid for by health insurance
The two men's claim aims to have the fact that they do not have a womb recognised as a 'disability': an absurd, envious and revealing claim. If they win in court all over America insurance companies and employers would have to reimburse gestations for other for men
A gay couple filed a lawsuit in New York labour court demanding that their employer-provided insurance company pay all the costs of the surrogate uterus for them, in order to ensure 'equal access to fertility treatment'. For all intents and purposes, they are demanding that a gay male couple become a protected category under the law because they are both without a womb and without access to one. If they win the case, in all [...]
Read now
5 July 2022
Mayor Beppe Sala's 'gift' to Pride
From now on, in Milan, the birth certificates of children of 'homogenous couples' will be automatically registered, including those born from surrogacy. Although the law and subsequent rulings firmly condemn the practice and point the way to 'adoption' for the 'intended' parent. But the registry office is the responsibility of the State, not of local administrations. And the Milanese have never been asked about it: all the critical aspects of a unilateral and very glamorous decision that could also present profiles of unconstitutionality
'We have restarted the recognition of children born in Italy by homogenous couples': the words with which Mayor Beppe Sala announced his personal 'gift' to Pride initially caused some confusion. In fact, children born 'in Italy' on the initiative of - and not 'by' - same-sex couples are only the children of women united with other women. The children of male couples are born in Canada, California or other procreative tourism destinations, but not in Italy [...].
Read now
1 May 2022
This is Georgia
Surrogacy, gender identity, motherhood: on many issues, the positions of the leader who now looks to the premiership coincide with those of feminism, snubbed by the left. What to do in the face of this challenge? Can the women's movement dialogue with the right?
Giorgia Meloni could become the first woman prime minister in our country. She no longer hides her ambition and if she knows how to do the right things by next spring - or rather, if she does not do the wrong things - and if she manages to escape the volleys of friendly fire, no less intense and insidious than enemy fire, she will be able to achieve her goal, having only herself to thank for the mistakes of her opponents: no one has co-opted her - see here - she has no master [...].
Read now
12 April 2022
Towards the abolition of surrogacy: an anthology and a debate
CIAMS publishes a multi-voice book against the uterus for rent and discusses it in an open webinar. In the meantime, in Italy, which is preparing to "welcome" the Fiera dell'Utero in Affitto (in Milan on 21-22 May), two bills are already being discussed that would extend the punishability of the practice even when carried out abroad. And a popular initiative bill is on the way
While in Italy we are preparing to "welcome" the Fair of the surrogate motherhood, scheduled for 21-22 May in a place still unknown - we will know only at the last minute - and in addition to the two bills already under discussion in the Commission of Justice of the Chamber of Deputies, proposals that call for the punishment of "surrogate motherhood even if carried out abroad, is preparing a draft law of popular initiative with a collection of signatures for a definitive stop to the practice - we will soon give details - next 28 April [...]
Read now
6 April 2022
There is a war in Ukraine. Do you go to Prague to rent wombs?
Sold as 'altruistic' - but with 'reimbursement of expenses' equal to Ukrainian rates - GPA could become a new business in the Czech Republic given the tragedy in Kiev, where children are not picked up by clients frightened by the conflict. With all-inclusive packages, including cultural attractions and good restaurants. Meanwhile, in Spain, a Supreme Court ruling reiterates the severe condemnation of the practice of "reducing women and children to merchandise".
A very recent ruling by the Supreme Court in Spain states that the surrogate motherhood violates the rights of mothers and children "treated as mere commodities", reiterating the ban. The High Court affirms that this type of contract "causes damage to the best interests of the child and an exploitation of women that is unacceptable" and violates the fundamental rights recognised by the Constitution and international conventions on human rights, and therefore "is therefore manifestly contrary to our public order". Both women and [...]
Read now
1 2 3 ... 13