30 March 2021
Kathleen Stock, docente di filosofia all'Università del Sussex, Uk

No more censorship in universities! Gender-critical prof fighting for freedom of speech

Please be aware that the translation of contents, although automatic, has a cost to Feminist Post but is provided to you without any charge. Please consider making a contribution via the "Support us" page if you intend to use our translation service intensively.
The contents of this site are translated using automatic translation systems without the intervention of professional translators.
Translations are provided for the sole purpose of facilitating reading by international visitors.
Share this article

"There is a stubbornness in me that does not tolerate being intimidated by the will of others.

My courage rises at every attempt to frighten me".

Jane Austen, Pride and Prejudice, 1813

An earthquake is shaking Anglo-Saxon universities. Provoking it gender critical professors who denounce, at the risk of their careers, the loss of academic freedom and the intimidating climate in discussing sex, gender and gender identity.

"The gender identity movement is erasing people's freedom of speech and the academic freedom of anyone who disagrees, openly opposes or appeals to the right to debate". This is supported by Donna Hughes, professor of Gender Studies at the University of Rhode Island, USA, who wrote an incendiary essay for the feminist website 4W, Fourth Wave.

In the essay, Hughes comes down hard. He writes: 'Believing that you can change your gender is a transsexual fantasy"and that " young people are driven to hormonal and surgical horrors removing sex". Not only that. Hughes denounces the fact that many people have started to pay the misgendering - the wrong gender attribution - with the loss of one's social account or even one's job. It then goes so far as to compare people whose gender identity is different from the sex registered at birth to the followers of Qanon and criticises the left, which has plunged headlong into a world of lies. Boom!

Basta censura nelle università! Prof gender critical in lotta per la libertà di parola

His comments were immediately condemned by the director of the university's Gender and Sexuality Center, Annie Russel, who called them 'unacceptable'. The University has distanced itself in a statement stating that they do not support statements expounding anti-transgender views. This was followed by a online smear campaign.

Hughes is not the only one who disagrees with the orthodoxy of her institution. In the UK Kathleen Stock, Professor of Philosophy at the University of Sussexrecently awarded an OBE for her work. campaign for academic freedom - and in particular that of examining the requests of pressure groups such as Stonewall - received in January a open letter signed by 600 people 'appalled' by his honour. Reason? His nefarious rhetoric. The email accusing Stock of transphobic scaremongeringof wanting to restrict people's access to life-saving medical treatment and of encouraging the harassment of gender non-conforming people. "It was incredibly stressful to see blatant lies presented as facts. But the letter also shows what a monstrous mess we are in when we talk about sex and gender"Stock retorts. He continues: 'I abhor discrimination against the trans world but I also believe in the freedom to examine the consequences of change, including the costs to women, gay rights and the health of children who want to change gender. As a lesbian with teenage children these topics are very close to me. And even more so as an academic and philosopher whose job it is to make sure that the investigating the truth. We must be free to discuss these things in public. Yet when I tried to do so I received complaints, disciplinary enquiries, protests from students, and constant defamation from colleagues.".

Stock has been isolated. "I have stopped attending philosophy conferences because I can no longer stand theostracism and dirty looks.. I walk through my department at the University of Sussex with a sense of dread. Two years ago the campus security manager shocked me by showing me the emergency phone system and had a peephole installed in the door. Later, when I was at a graduation I was joined by security who showed me the quickest way to leave the stage during an emergency.I was no longer shocked - the experience had become normal.".

Removed from TwitterStock has released amuch discussed interview with Charlie Hebdo where accused the liberal feminism of middle-class university students of surrendering to the militant trans movement and moving away from the working class.

For those who work in the university, the message is clear: either you conform to the dominant narrative or you come to a bad end. It is no coincidence that other academics such as Selina Todd, Oxford history, has a ssecurity service for its conferences e Alice Sullivanprofessor of sociology at University College London was removed - no platforming - from an event on census data collection guidelines. Is this a new witch-hunt? Silence is violence.

Basta censura nelle università! Prof gender critical in lotta per la libertà di parola
Oxford historian Selina Todd

To rebel against this culture GCAcademia Network, a site where gender-critical lecturers and students denounce anonymously the intimidating climate, bullying, threats and basically the death of academic debate, was born. Chilling testimonies that once again measure the suffocating climate and loss of freedom in universities. One lecturer: "They encourage us to state and use pronouns and to confessing whether we are cis or trans. Teaching Women and Gender Studies has become a nightmare that no one wants to talk about anymore.. Queer Theory dominates everywhere". A student studying English Literature: "I recently had a paper corrected where have replaced every time I have written 'female' or 'sex' with 'gender' and 'gender identity'. Some phrasesthey don't even make sense anymore. I thought the point of doing university was to support freedom of expression and to promote discussion and debate. I feel like leaving".

Basta censura nelle università! Prof gender critical in lotta per la libertà di parola
Alice Sullivan Professor of Sociology UCL

Another student from the University of Edinburgh: "We are asked to use terminology approved by Stonewall and to talk about sex assigned at birth. and the true gender of people". University feminist groups are not safe either. "I am a Fine Art student at a university in the UK. I joined the Feminist Society thinking of finding a space where we can discuss feminism freely. The first session on Zoom was opened by a man using the pronouns She/Her. He spoke in place of women as if he were a woman. even though he had obviously never experienced sexism in his life because he was clearly a sexist. a man with female pronouns. I was shocked but if I had intervened I would have been accused of transphobia and racism".  

Nina Wess 30 March 2021

Micromega magazine also hosts a text on these issues

Most of the news published by Feminist Post you will not read about them elsewhere. That is why it is important to support us, even with a small contribution: Feminist Post is produced solely by the voluntary work of many people and has no funding. If you think our work can be useful for your life, we would be grateful for even the smallest contribution.  



IBAN: IT80C0200812914000104838541

Much of the news published by Feminist Post you will not read elsewhere. That is why it is important to support us, even with a small contribution: Feminist Post is produced solely by the voluntary work of many people and has no funding.
If you think our work can be useful for your life, we will be grateful for even the smallest contribution.

You can give us your contribution by clicking here: Patreon - Feminist Post
   - or -
Obligatory reason: FEMINIST POST
IBAN: IT80C0200812914000104838541
You might also be interested in
10 May 2022
Kathleen Stock: 5 tips to keep transactivist troublemakers quiet
The lecturer forced to resign for saying that biological sex exists explains how to deal with harassing transactivism: just like a mother dealing with a wayward child or rebellious teenager. An ironic guide to saving your life
Philosopher Kathleen Stock became known outside academic circles after she was forced to resign from her professorship at the University of Sussex with threats and defamation by transactivists for expressing critical views on gender identity (see here). While similar cases are happening all over the world, including Italy and Europe (see here and here), in Anglo-Saxon countries lecturers are organising themselves to fight against the censorship of gender-critical feminism. In the article we present Kathleen [...]
Read now
19 February 2022
Trans-athlete Petrillo wins it all. And - of course - thinks about politics
Fabrizio-Valentina Petrillo continues to rout opponents. Her last podium finish was at the 200m indoor masters championships in Ancona. She says that sport divided by gender is violence. And she proclaims her motto-manifesto: "Everyone must have the opportunity to determine for themselves who they are". Starting with gender
Between the Olympics and the DDL Zan last year, sports publications devoted a lot of space to 'inclusive sport' and to Valentina born Fabrizio Petrillo, presented as the 'first transgender athlete to wear the Italian national team jersey in an international competition'. Petrillo, who competes both in Paralympic competitions for the visually impaired and in the masters championships for female athletes over 35 (here is the entry of the athletes beaten by her male body), hoped until the very end to participate in the female category at the Paralympic Games in Tokyo. The qualification [...]
Read now
3 December 2021
New Forstater case in UK: lawyer sues Stonewall for 'inducing discrimination'
Allison Bailey was allegedly mobbed and discriminated against by her law firm for expressing her opposition to gender self-certification or self-id. A lesbian and founder of the LGBT Alliance, she sued the firm and Stonewall as well. Who, she is convinced, actively worked for her "punishment".
Stonewall will face a court case for encouraging the law firm where Allison Bailey, a lesbian lawyer, works to issue a disciplinary measure against her just because she had criticised transgender activists. The lawyer filed a discrimination complaint inspired by the case of Maya Forstater, the researcher at the Center for Global Development in London who lost her job for expressing her opposition to gender self-certification (see here). On 10 June, an appeals court ruled that Maya Forstater had [...].
Read now
24 November 2021
Stonewall backtracks and 'authorises' the use of the word mother
After losing agreements with some big companies, including the Health Service and the BBC - and therefore a lot of money - the UK's largest LGBT+ organisation moderately updates its guidelines for "inclusiveness": it will no longer be required to use terms like "pregnant person" or "person who has given birth" instead of mother. Change of course = no-bankruptcy
Stonewall has dropped legislation advising workplace equality organisations to remove the word 'mother' from their policies. The lobby announced that it would no longer reward with higher ranking scores employers who would adopt gender-neutral alternatives by starting to use "mother". Nancy Kelley, Stonewall's chief executive, denied in an interview that such a policy existed. "We are not interested in removing or deleting the [...]
Read now
3 November 2021
British government breaks with Stonewall
The Department of Health breaks its agreement with the large LGBTQ organisation, paid hundreds of thousands of pounds to lobby, imposing the'use of pronouns and free access for anyone to women's spaces based on free gender identity. Great news for British women and for all of us.
The British Department of Health has broken its agreement with Stonewall: it will no longer use its consultancy (lavishly paid: more than £300,000 of taxpayers' money paid to the big organisation so far) to apply its diversity scheme in favour of LGBT staff. The Department of Health is the latest high-profile organisation to distance itself from the lobby group, which has been heavily criticised for its influence and intrusiveness into public policy. A Department spokeswoman said: 'The year [...]
Read now
29 October 2021
Kathleen Stock has resigned: 'The witch is dead'.
This is how the students of the University of Sussex, who had threatened the teacher and demanded her dismissal, celebrated her resignation. The decision was taken after "an absolutely horrible time for me and my family". Tiepid support from the university, while other academics attack her: her defence of sex against gender reinforces "the patriarchal status quo".
Kathleen Stock, the philosophy lecturer at the centre of a controversy over her views on gender identification and transgender rights, has announced her resignation from the University of Sussex. Stock's resignation comes three weeks after a protest by some students on the university's Brighton campus, which included posters and graffiti calling for her dismissal. Stock believes that gender identity matters no more than biological sex "when it comes to laws and policies" and that people [...]
Read now
1 2 3 ... 19