Omission on Malika

Share this article

Malika's story is horrifying, that's for sure. When expressions like “I will cut your throat", things are going very badly indeed. They probably are usual expressions when domestic violence occurs. And violence against women is an incredibly widespread phenomenon. Only this time, unlike usual, the verbal violence was recorded and broadcast online and on TV.

Malika Chalhy has a brother called Samir, her father is called Aberrazak (the origin is Moroccan). The mother, however, is Italian. Take a photo with the whole veiled family: the photo is real - taken from the father's FB profile - it is not a fake, but women wear the veil on the occasion of a party. We therefore do not know whether Malika's family is a traditionalist Islamic family. However, we know for sure that all the media deliberately failed to say that Malika's father is of Muslim culture.

It may be that this (difficult) has nothing to do with the family's behavior towards the girl. Instead, it may be that the origins offer a significant key to understanding.

Even more than the mother's terrible, visceral and angry words, they are striking the threats from his brother Samir: "I'll cut your throat", "you're a lesbian tumor". Today it is quite difficult for a boy in his twenties to react this way to the news that his sister is homosexual. He can feel bad about it, remain perfectly indifferent or sympathize with her. That type of reaction speaks of a culture of control, possession and domination which today in our area, among brothers and sisters, is completely unusual (it hasn't been in the past). So of a robustly patriarchal attitude, which pertains to the duty to save the honor of the family, transmitted in a patrilineal key and guaranteed by the women of the house forced to transmit "values" and genealogical self-sexism. But here we move into the field of hypotheses.

Remaining certain: Malika was treated horribly; the media deliberately chose not to talk about the family's origins. An ideological choice which is very similar to the silence on "ethnic" rapes in Northern Europe: the Swedish police themselves admitted that for a long time they had remained silent on sexual violence committed by young immigrants so as not to offer arguments to the xenophobic right. Also in this case it is considered more appropriate and more correct to focus the lens on generalized homophobia than on the culture of patriarchal domination.

But the story of Malika, who rightly rebelled, could perhaps resemble that of the Pakistani-Brescia Hina Saleem more than it appears, killed by her father with the help of relatives because she had an Italian boyfriend and wanted to live like all her friends: 12 years after her death her brother Suleman removed the photo from her grave in the cemetery because in that image she appeared "too undressed" . It could, I say: but thereThe hypothesis must be taken into account. And it cannot be taken into account if, against all ethics, the media hide part of the news, we could even say they censor it so as not to ask for trouble and not appear culturally incorrect.

Hina Saleem

From “internal” half-breed (father from the North, mother of Southern origins), my life and my body have been a battlefield between a violently patriarchal culture, paradoxically embodied by a mother who was also a victim and rebel, and a decidedly more open culture of which she was bearer my father, son and grandson of already emancipated women. I know those dynamics intimately, and I recognize them every time with deep pain.

Perhaps Malika is a victim of homophobia, and is well suited as a symbol of the battle for the Zan bill - which should focus on this and forget about gender identity -. Or maybe things wouldn't have been different if Malika had a male boyfriend she didn't like at home. Perhaps, more ordinarily - and it's all part of it - Malika is a victim of male domination, the one that fills the statistics and in its "naturalness" continues not to make the news.

Marina Terragni

Much of the news published by Feminist Post you won't read them anywhere else. This is why it is important to support us, even with a small contribution: Feminist Post it is produced solely thanks to the voluntary work of many and does not benefit from any funding. If you think our work could be useful for your life, we will be grateful for even the smallest contribution.  

You can send to: BLU BRAMANTE CULTURAL ASSOCIATION

MANDATORY REASON: FEMINIST POST

IBAN: IT80C0200812914000104838541


This article is produced through voluntary work.
Much of the news you read here you won't find in any other media.
If you think our work is useful, thank you if you can support us.
Even the smallest contribution is precious!

You can make a bank transfer to:
RadFem Italia Association
IBAN: IT59W0306909606100000402734

Share this article
Scroll to Top