Uterus transplantation for trans MtF (male born)

Not only 'pregnant men' (trans FtMs, born women) as covered by L'Espresso: bioethical criteria for uterus transplants have recently been revised. The uterus can also be received by trans-MTFs, i.e. biologically male. For a complete transition
Please be aware that the translation of contents, although automatic, has a cost to Feminist Post but is provided to you without any charge. Please consider making a contribution via the "Support us" page if you intend to use our translation service intensively.
The contents of this site are translated using automatic translation systems without the intervention of professional translators.
Translations are provided for the sole purpose of facilitating reading by international visitors.
Share this article

The cover of the latest issue of l'Espresso probably appears to most as a provocation. Those who follow certain scientific literature, however, know that what has been designed is already reality, and has been for some time.. Pregnancies in women who identify themselves as men - FtM, the acronym (Female to Male) - like the one drawn on the cover of the weekly magazine - are certainly nothing new: just look in the sector databases (Scopus o WOS o Pubmedrecognised for scientific publications assessed for university competitions) and consult the extensive literature emerging.

By way of example, in 2014 the magazine Obstetric & Gynecology  (of the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists) published an article entitled Transgender Men Who Experienced Pregnancy After Female-to-Male Gender Transition, on a study approved by the University of California, San Francisco Committee on Human Research. Twenty-five FtM used testosterone before pregnancy and only six of them were unplanned; most of them had their babies with their partners, five had recourse to anonymous donors or sperm banks, three to known donors, 21 with their own oocytes. And recently, scholars from the Rutger Robert Wood Johnson Medical School, New Brunswick, in the USA, on the obstetrical treatments for 'transgender men with advanced paternal age', i.e. FtM with more than 35 years of age, whose advanced age is defined as "but at the same time we talk about labour, childbirth and the etc. We don't know how many FtM births there are so far, but according to experts these numbers are increasing.

On the other hand, for some time now there has been ample space in the scientific literature for 'transgender health', which includes the health of transgender people. fertility preservation treatmentsThe aim is clear: to be able to be genetic mothers in the future (and also gestational mothers if they do not undergo a hysterectomy) and biological fathers by being, respectively, social and often anagraphic fathers and mothers. It should be remembered that the possibility of these treatments is also offered to adolescents, including those given puberty blockers, provided, of course, that sufficient sexual maturity has been attained: it remains a mystery as to how a 13-year-old could be aware of this, when expressing their informed consent in this regard, just as doubts remain as to the real freedom of consent of parents, who are called upon to give legal approval to these paths.

It is still at the level of academic discussion, however, that the possibility of uterus transplantation to 'transgender individuals': the journal Bioethics recently published an article whose lead author is Jacques Balayla, a gynaecologist at McGill University, in Montreal, Canada. He is one of the three signatories of the "Montreal criteria', i.e. the international ethical reference criteria for uterine transplants. It should be noted that the text was updated by the same authors in 2013, a year after publication, with some ethical openings to uterus transplantation in men or trans women, but confirming its exclusion from the clinical point of view. In the article published this year, the ethical reasoning is resumed by re-reading the first of the required criteria - the recipient is a genetic female of reproductive age with no medical contraindications to transplantation - because "the condition that the patient is a genetic female inherently disqualifies transgender, certain non-binary, gender-diverse and cis-gender women who have a non-XX karyotype ("transgender UTx")", where UTx stands for "uterine transplantation".  

The authors state that so far there have been no uterus transplants on 'transgender UTx', but in the article they develop a number of arguments to show that this is not the case.ethical acceptability, with reference to the well-known bioethical principles of autonomy, non-maleficence, beneficence and justice. The Montreal Charter is then reread with comments such as "If a cis-gender person who identifies as female but lacks a womb can ethically have one, then the principle of justice indicates that this opportunity should be offered to all such persons, regardless of the circumstances of their birth.". And if the purpose of uterine transplantation according to the Montreal Charter is to procure a pregnancy, invoking the principle of beneficence can be thought of as "making uterine transplants available to those suffering from gender dysphoria"as long as clinical safety criteria are met. UTx could become 'part of gender reassignment surgery', therefore, as also argued in earlier work by a team of British surgeons, cited in the article.

Finally, some considerations on the construction of the possible vaginal access to the uterine cavity: the authors felt the need to specify, to avoid misunderstandings, that this is a treatment applicable only to trans-females and not to trans-females. for cis-males, the latter being called upon if they were hypothetically interested in carrying a pregnancy without gender transition. In a few words and without emphasis, that's where you want to go with this.

(for the incredulous, in the original textAs we mentioned previously, though UTx may well be transitory to void the need for lifelong immune-suppression, the gender re-assignment surgery and orchiectomy needed to ensure the success of UTx are permanent - a consideration that would not apply to cis-males who would seek to carry pregnancy without transitioning. Indeed the ready convenience of access to the uterine cavity both for embryo transfer and biopsy via the cervix prefers that a transgender patient seeking to become pregnant through UTx should have previously undergone surgical construction of a neo-vagina that may be connected to the transplanted canal and cervix. Such a reality would only apply to trans-females and not cis-males).

Assuntina Morresi

Much of the news published by Feminist Post you will not read elsewhere. That is why it is important to support us, even with a small contribution: Feminist Post is produced solely by the voluntary work of many people and has no funding.
If you think our work can be useful for your life, we will be grateful for even the smallest contribution.

You can give us your contribution by clicking here: Patreon - Feminist Post
You might also be interested in
26 May 2023
This time it is: in the skin of children
Against the ruling of the Court of Cassation, which prevents the full transcription of birth certificates of children born from surrogacy by allowing only the biological parent to be named and indicating stepchild adoption for his or her partner, some male couples in Milan are undertaking a new form of resistance: not even registering the biological parent - or both or neither - leaving the child in an administrative limbo in which, in this case, he or she would be deprived of the most elementary rights, from paediatrician to school
After the Prefecture of Milan, in application of a ruling by the Court of Cassation, blocked the transcription of the full birth certificates of children born on the initiative of same-sex couples - indicating that only the biological parent should be transcribed and the stepchild adoption, i.e. adoption in special cases, which is perfectly legitimate, should be the only way forward - the municipality of Milan is experiencing this, according to the report by Roberta Osculati, PD vice-president of the City Council: same-sex couples [...].
Read now
15 May 2023
Jama: when men give birth
In an incredible, recently published study, the American Medical Association's journal, one of the most important in the field, tries to give scientific backing to the idea that childbirth is not just a female experience. Because if it were exclusive, it would also be exclusionary. An operation on language in collision with reality
As we know, there are words that can no longer be used, especially in international scientific documents and studies. At the top of the list of tabooed words are all the terms that have to do with female difference understood as the exclusive possibility of giving birth to human beings, and thus: 'woman' -if biologically understood and not open to define persons not born women-, 'mother' and 'maternal', 'breast', with reference to breast-feeding, and so on. The operation on language aims to qualify [...].
Read now
13 May 2023
Legislation against violence against women should talk about sex and not 'gender identity': open letter to the European Parliament
Violence against women will not be combated if the texts of laws and treaties do not clearly refer to sex and not 'gender'. We join feminist and gender critical groups in an appeal to MEPs who will vote on the Commission's anti-violence proposal: write clearly in the text that women and girls are the female sex and leave no room for gender ideology
We, too, signed the letter to the European Commission on combating violence against women and domestic abuse drafted by WORIADS, a coalition of gender-critical citizens whose aim is to inform and raise awareness of the dangers of gender identity in the European institutions. The letter demands that European regulations on violence against women clearly recognise the category of biological sex. Below is the full text that will be sent to the members of the European Parliament who will vote on the [...].
Read now
11 May 2023
The Istanbul Convention belongs to women! The Right does not obstruct Europe's ratification
By abstaining from yesterday's vote, preliminary to the European accession to the most important treaty against violence against women, the MEPs of the Lega and Fratelli d'Italia gave in to the pressure of the Pro Vita, who read that document as anti-family and pro-gender (the same concerns expressed by Turkish Prime Minister Erdogan). But Italy has already acceded to the Convention and apparently this is not the government's orientation. And Lgbtq claims have nothing to do with it. Women between two misogynist fires: religious extremism and queer instrumentalisation
Yesterday, a resolution was passed in Europe calling on the EU to accede to the Istanbul Convention (2011), the most important international treaty -legally binding- against violence against women and domestic violence. Italy has already ratified the Convention in 2013, while 6 European countries (Bulgaria, Czechia, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania and Slovakia) have not yet done so. Yesterday's vote is preliminary to the accession of the entire EU to the Convention. Incredibly, the MEPs of Fratelli d'Italia and the Lega abstained from the vote. [...]
Read now
8 May 2023
The Bundestag is preparing to vote on a proposal modelled on the horrible Spanish law that allows free choice of gender even for minors with a simple self-declaration at the registry office (in addition to the possibility of changing one's mind several times). Also in the front line here is a left-wing woman counterpart of Irene Montero: the Green Minister for Women's Affairs Lisa Paus. But the opinion of the Federal Constitutional Court, which expresses many doubts about the deletion of the category 'sex', will be needed.
What is a woman? The answer that Justice Minister Buschmann (FDP, Liberal Democratic Party) and Women's Affairs Minister Lisa Paus (Greens, pictured) give to this question is: a woman is anyone who claims to be a woman. This is the core of the 'bill on self-determination in gender registration' that both ministries have now presented. With a simple declaration at the registry office, everyone will in future be able to change their sex: from male to [...]
Read now
5 May 2023
The 'wheel' is not enough: help for mothers who wish to be mothers
Cots for life and the possibility of giving birth anonymously are very important. But the note left by the mother of Noemi, the baby left at the Red Cross headquarters in Bergamo, speaks of a desire that circumstances have made impracticable. What is needed is a place where, when they want to be mothers, women in difficulty can find all the support and assistance they need
The little girl left by her mother in the Cradle for Life in Bergamo - once called Ruota - has been given the name Noemi. Noemi will soon have a family and a home, and for her we wish 'all the good and happiness in the world', as her mother wished in a touching note that in just a few lines succeeds in recounting a life: 'Born this morning 3/5/2023, at home. Just me and her as in these 9 months. I can't, but [...]
Read now
1 2 3 ... 44