Mail-bombing to Repubblica: Misinformation on puberty blockers is unacceptable
In an article lacking scientific evidence, Michela Marzano claims that the effects of puberty blockers administered to "gender non-conforming" girls would be perfectly reversible, a fact contradicted by studies and clinical practice. And he talks about a greater risk of suicide for these minors, risks that have never been proven. Here is the scientifically argued text of a letter to be sent to director Molinari to request more accurate and less ideological information on such a delicate topic

Share this article

Text for a Mail-bombing, to be sent to the director Maurizio Molinari m.molinari@repubblica.it


Gentle Director Molinari,

let's read the article by Michela Marzano, headline “Hands off gender identity”, published in your newspaper on Sunday 5 February. And we cannot fail to note with dismay that theThe author addresses the very delicate issue of "dysphoric" minors without any scientific reference, maintaining among other things that "the suspension" induced by drugs that block puberty "is temporary and reversible", that the use of said drugs "allows time to pass, and therefore gives adolescents the opportunity to mature, without forcing them to live with that profound desperation which, very often (and we know it!) leads to suicide".

As for the supposed "reversibility" of the effects produced by blockers, this is a fact denied by various studies (see as an example the article published by British Medical Journal) as well as clinical practice. An effect now established as irreversible is bone demineralization: the study talks about reduced growth in height and bone strength.

Even if the girl or boy (the administration is pre-pubertal, it is therefore a question of children between 9 and 12 years old) suspended the “therapy”, i bone problems and very early osteopenia would be irreversible, as well as other possible effects being studied, come on risks for fertility, for the nervous system and other. In truth, the "therapy" is almost never interrupted, considering the percentage of minors you give blocker switches to cross-sex hormone intake largely exceeds 90%, therefore the blocker they do not give "time to time" but actually start the transition.

Another study published by the journalEndocrine Society highlights that physiological late puberty is associated with risk of numerous diseases in adulthood, such as obesity, type 2 diabetes and cardiovascular problems, in addition to the one already mentioned osteoporosis and to problems of mental health. These risks apply even if puberty is deliberately delayed with the use of blockers.  

Precisely on the basis of this and other evidence in many pioneer nations of these treatments there has been an abrupt change of direction: the Tavistock Clinic London, center of excellence in the UK, was closed after numerous scandals and following the resulting investigations, with extensive discussion in the major English newspapers - is it possible that Marzano is not aware of this? -. Same fate for its Swedish counterpart, the Karolinska Institute in Stockholm, that has had to admit that he had ruined the health of girls and boys exposing them to the risk of “serious injury” And agreeing that there are insufficient studies to demonstrate whether hormone treatment is useful and safe for minors.  Hormone treatment, it is argued, should continue to be administered only in the context of precise studies, which are currently lacking. It can therefore be said without any doubt that “therapy” with i puberty blocker it is experimental. Based on the findings, the conclusion of the Swedish National Board of Health and Welfare is that The risks of anti-puberty treatment and sex confirmatory hormone treatment for children under 18 currently outweigh the possible benefits.

There is also a brake in Norway, in Finland, in many American states, in Australia, even in Holland where the “affirmative” drug-based model was invented in 2006 (in fact it is called the “Dutch protocol”) and where we return to giving priority to the psychological and psychiatric approach.

As for "giving time to time", as Marzano claims, to allow girls and boys "to mature", it is the exact opposite: it is precisely the blockers that prevent physiological maturation, sexual development and a clearer understanding of oneself. Associations such as explain it LGB Alliance And Lesbian United which define drug therapy on minors as essentially homophobic practice given that the large part of these girls and boys over time would discover themselves to be "simply" homosexual.

Finally, and there is much more to note, the risk of suicide mentioned by Marzano: nThere is no study that ascertains a greater risk of suicide in minors with supposed gender dysphoria -supposed because, as is now common knowledge, many of these minors suffer from autism spectrum disorders, depression or other mental problems-, nor does it compare the risk of suicide among the “dysphoric” minors they employ blocker with that among minors who do not take them. It cannot be argued that i blocker alleviate negative thoughts among minors with dysphoria. Since it concerns the life and suffering of many children and their families, Marzano shouldn't talk about suicide risk without precise evidence.

We hope that your newspaper can host less approximate interventions on such a delicate issue, opening up to a non-ideological debate based on scientific data, similarly to what occurs in the major international media. And also taking into account the fact that the ideological approach contributes to the "epidemic" of dysphoria among minors, a social contagion admitted even by WPATH, leading global association for transgender health, in one recent interview with the New York Times. 

With request for publication

Network for the Inviolability of the Female Body

GeneraAzioneD, an association of parents of teenagers and pre-teens who have identified as transgender


This article is produced through voluntary work.
Much of the news you read here you won't find in any other media.
If you think our work is useful, thank you if you can support us.
Even the smallest contribution is precious!

You can make a bank transfer to:
RadFem Italia Association
IBAN: IT59W0306909606100000402734

Share this article
Scroll to Top