Feminism and Zan law

Please be aware that the translation of contents, although automatic, has a cost to Feminist Post but is provided to you without any charge. Please consider making a contribution via the "Support us" page if you intend to use our translation service intensively.
The contents of this site are translated using automatic translation systems without the intervention of professional translators.
Translations are provided for the sole purpose of facilitating reading by international visitors.
Share this article

In these hours, the LGBT+ world is mobilising to ask the Senate Justice Commission to schedule the Zan bill against homobitransphobia, misogyny and ableism, which has already been approved by the Chamber of Deputies. Arcilesbica has drafted some proposals for amendments without which, he says, 'there is a risk of serious damage'. These, in brief, are the proposals addressed to the centre-left's senator-ministers.

- in the definitions in Article 1, using the clear terms of 'sex, gender stereotypes, sexual orientation, transsexuality', instead of the current ambiguities (sex, gender, sexual orientation and gender identity)

- make it explicit that the bill is consistent with the existing ban on womb renting. Being against gpa is not homophobia

- make it explicit that the bill is consistent with the current law 164/82 (which regulates the rectification of 'sex change', ed) and with the subsequent Constitutional Court judgment 180/2017 which states that for sex change "the voluntarist element alone cannot have priority or exclusive importance". Being against gender self-certification (self-id) is not transphobia.

Arcilesbica's position is relevant mainly because it comes from within the LGBT+ world concerned by the law.

But apparently all women, of whatever sexual orientation, and people with disabilities are equally affected by the law, and this is due to the specific will of the signatories who have provided themselves with these facilitating" fig leavesWho would dare to vote against a law that also defends women, all of them, and the disabled? Inclusion' follows the traditional phallogocentric formulas that have always been used in Italian politics, in which, after 'naturally' referring to the male subject, 'young people, the elderly, women, the disabled' and any other subject deemed 'marginal' were also added.

As we have always said, therefore, We consider it important to remove the fight against misogyny (represented by the word 'sex') from the text of the bill. Women are not one of several minorities to be protected, they are the majority of mankind.

For some time now, feminism, particularly Anglo-Saxon feminism, has been undergoing a complex debate on the appropriateness of laws against misogyny as a hate crime (see here), an opportunity on which positions are still differentiated. The time and manner of this discussion between women must be respected and cannot be 'paternalistically' bypassed by men for opportunistic reasons. Ad abundantiam: very often there have been real conflicts between legislation protecting LGBT+ and women's reasons/interestsas he explains very well here Julie Bindel. So: Misogyny out of the Zan bill.

There is at least one other significant theme, which concerns the "Lgbtq+ 'training' in schools. During the debate that led to the approval of the bill in the Chamber, the majority rejected even very reasonable amendments making participation in these 'courses' conditional on parental consent, at least for primary and secondary school pupils.. Participation would therefore be compulsory, in absolute contrast to the Anglo-Saxon world where, after years of these practices and having seen the damage, governments are putting the brakes on: In the UK, for example, LGBT+ associations such as Mermaids are no longer allowed to 'train' in schools of all levels. Vice versa in Italian schools these occasions are multiplying, in particular the propaganda initiatives for 'free gender identity' and the 'surrogate mother', while any educational proposal by women that does not focus on LGBT+ rights has no place in schools and universities (this is the so-called no-platforming, see here e here).

Finally, the question of the guarantees for the free expression of thoughtwith particular reference to the thought of radical and gender-critical feminism, if it is true that, as explained by the first signatory of the lagge Mr Zan himself "the law is to instil an attitude of caution in people. "Prudence', which is already being 'instilled' everywhere - in newspapers, in academies, on social networks - with bans and lawsuits. (see here).

In our opinion, therefore, The excellent proposal drawn up by Arcilesbica should be supplemented (and amended where it does not discuss the fact that the law also covers women).

As you can see in this tweet from WHRC Norway, just 3 months after the approval of a law that includes gender identity as a possible object of hate crimes, MP Jenny Klinge was denounced for saying that 'only women give birth'..

This is what awaits us.

Il femminismo e la legge Zan

It is also hoped that, should the bill be calendared, the reasons long expressed by feminism (you can find them in this petition) are finally being heard: so far this has not happened, contrary to what the former leader of the PD group in the Chamber stated in his final explanation of vote. More precisely, that there is finally the possibility of be heard in the Commission for Justice.

Marina Terragni


Most of the news published by Feminist Post you will not read about them elsewhere. That is why it is important to support us, even with a small contribution: Feminist Post is produced solely by the voluntary work of many people and has no funding. If you think our work can be useful for your life, we would be grateful for even the smallest contribution.  

Please send to: BLU BRAMANTE CULTURAL ASSOCIATION

OBLIGATORY REASON: FEMINIST POST

IBAN: IT80C0200812914000104838541


Much of the news published by Feminist Post you will not read elsewhere. That is why it is important to support us, even with a small contribution: Feminist Post is produced solely by the voluntary work of many people and has no funding.
If you think our work can be useful for your life, we will be grateful for even the smallest contribution.

You can give us your contribution by clicking here: Patreon - Feminist Post
   - or -
You can send to: ASSOCIAZIONE CULTURALE BLU BRAMANTE
Obligatory reason: FEMINIST POST
IBAN: IT80C0200812914000104838541
You might also be interested in
26 November 2022
Citizenship Income Reform: taking sexual difference into account
The employment situation and wage levels of women -with strong regional variability- are very different between women and men. This was also the case for income, which also had a positive effect on the birth rate. This is why changing the institution requires a careful assessment of the so-called 'gender impact': an 'equal' reform could have unequal effects according to gender
The need for a citizenship income reform is now recognised across the board, albeit with different approaches and solutions. The Meloni government has presented its plan in progress. But the consideration of what is called the 'gender impact' -that is, the evaluation of the effects of the reform on women- still seems insufficient, generally underestimated by analyses. In a social situation and in a labour market like the Italian one, where women are strongly disadvantaged both in [...]
Read now
21 November 2022
Prostitution 'clients' know full well that they are committing violence
Research on sex buyers shows that men are fully aware that prostitution is violence, that criminal organisations keep women in fear and that there is no 'regulation' that holds. But they only stop if they risk a criminal conviction, as is the case in Sweden, Norway, Canada, France, Ireland, Israel and other countries that have introduced the abolitionist model. Otherwise, they continue to consider date rape as their right
by Julie Bindel Germany is known as the brothel of Europe. It is a hard-won title. With more than 3,000 brothels across the country, and 500 in Berlin alone, its sex trade is worth more than £11 billion a year. Prostitution, in all its forms, has been legal in Germany since the end of World War II. Recently, however, attitudes are changing. People and politicians are asking the government to take notice of the so-called 'pimp state' and [...]
Read now
7 November 2022
Belgium, new feminicide law. To be studied
In Europe, male violence is the leading cause of death for women between the ages of 16 and 44. Belgium equips itself with a new law that for the first time legally defines feminicides in order to develop policies based on official statistics. Keeping in mind that violence is a device of male domination
Stop the slaughter of women. This is the meaning of the new 'law on the prevention of and fight against feminicides, gender-based crimes and the violence that precedes them' adopted at first reading in the Council of Ministers on 25 October in Belgium. Deposed by the Secretary of State for Gender Equality, Sarah Schlitz (Ecolo/Verdi), the framework law for the first time legally defines feminicides in order to develop combat policies based on official statistics. And in [...]
Read now
29 October 2022
The name of the premier
Giorgia Meloni is not a feminist. Her history is not this. She has not shared in the long battles over language, over declension into the feminine instead of the neuter-masculine. But language today is a battleground that structures the most important political issues. And it deserves further reflection on her part
Giorgia Meloni is not a feminist. That is not her story. No woman on the right or centre-right who has held important political office, from Thatcher to Merkel, has ever called herself a feminist. Hence the non-sensitivity to the feminine declination of office, to which feminism instead attaches importance. Even if Angela Merkel at the end of her long chancellorship, during a meeting with the writer Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie, agreed to call herself a feminist. According to Alice Schwarzer, founder of the [...]
Read now
27 October 2022
England: new guidelines for 'trans' minors
While Spain is about to approve the horrifying Ley Trans, which allows the transition of girls from the age of 12 even if their parents oppose it, the English health service closes once and for all with the so-called pharmacological 'affirmative approach' (puberty blockers) practised for years and points to psychological treatment as the priority route. And in Italy? For the Italian Society of Paediatrics, these drugs do not cause any problems and their effects are completely 'reversible', a fact denied by several studies
The English health service (NHS) has published a new draft of guidelines for the treatment of children with gender dysphoria (full text here), pending the results of the Cass Review, an independent enquiry commissioned by the British health minister and led by paediatrician Hilary Cass (see here), which will lead to a complete restructuring of services dedicated to gender non-conforming children. After the closure of the Tavistock clinic -which we told you about here-, NHS puts a definitive end to the so-called [...]
Read now
21 October 2022
Women-containers: pro-life and pro-utero for hire see eye to eye
For one and the other, the female body must make itself available to 'produce' the unborn child by renouncing the possibility of choice once pregnancy has begun. But a new life only really begins when there is a maternal yes: a fact that is unattainable and unattainable by law. Otherwise the only possibility is compulsion.
At least three things can be said about the bill filed by Maurizio Gasparri to amend Article 1 of the Civil Code and introduce into our legal system the recognition of the legal capacity of the conceived 'with the intention of preventing voluntary abortion in any form, whether legal or clandestine'. The first: it is highly unlikely that the bill will reach parliamentary halls. The immediate consequence of its approval would be the substantial inapplicability of law 194 because abortion would in fact be tantamount to murder. None of the majority forces [...]
Read now
1 2 3 ... 43