28 July 2022

Petrillo's stolen records: 'But I also won as a man'. Is this true? Here's the fact-checking

While the Olympic Committee announces a change in the guidelines on the participation of male bodies in women's sports, Valentina born Fabrizio Petrillo aspires to participate in the Paralympic Games in the women's category. To those who accuse her of wanting to win easily, she replies that she was winning even before the transition. But this is not the case: here is an analysis of Petrillo's times and how they are evaluated in the male and female categories respectively
Please be aware that the translation of contents, although automatic, has a cost to Feminist Post but is provided to you without any charge. Please consider making a contribution via the "Support us" page if you intend to use our translation service intensively.
The contents of this site are translated using automatic translation systems without the intervention of professional translators.
Translations are provided for the sole purpose of facilitating reading by international visitors.
Share this article

After the international federations of swimming, cycling and other sports, even the Olympic Committee is backtracking on the 'inclusion' of male bodies in women's sports.

Francesco Ricci Bitti at the head of ASOIF, the association that brings together the international federations of summer Olympic sports, announced at a recent conference the need to review the current rules on the participation of transgender athletes, mainly MtF, men who 'identify themselves as women'.

Francesco Ricci Bitti said: 'According to the human rights approach, 'transgender women' [MTF athletes] should live a normal life. This is absolutely true, but perhaps not in the world of elite professional sport'. He went on to emphasise that inclusion is a social value, so it should not be the first criterion to be followed in the composition of sports regulations: 'Eligibility rules regarding restrictions should be first and foremost based on science and designed to preserve fairness in top-level competitions. I believe that the latest guidelines are too evasive and therefore we must improve them or else we will lose [competitiveness] levels."(see here).

Meanwhile, in Italy MtoF athlete Valentina born Fabrizio Petrillo continues to reap victories in women's athletics (see here). Last month we reported on his participation -as a member of the Italian women's national team- at the World Para Athletics Grand Prix in Paris, an important test ahead of the Paris 2024 Paralympic Games.

And Valentina did not disappoint expectations, bringing home a gold in the 400 metres T13 and a new Italian women's record. A week later, in a competition in Grosseto on 17 June, she also set a new record in the 200 metres T13, improving a record she already held (here).

In short, When Petrillo runs, Italian records in the various distances of Paralympic women's running almost always have to be updated. Yet 'Valentina' In his interviews he has always denied any advantage due to being born a man.

Today we present an analysis of Petrillo's times in context, performed by statistician Marco Alciator. Alciator has compared Petrillo's times and records with those of international male and female athletes, also explaining the different evaluation of similar performances depending on whether the category is male or female.

The data clearly show a situation of absolute anomaly in the Petrillo case, with roughly the same times as when he competed as Fabrizio, moving up to the women's category also started winning in international competitions, a privilege granted only to male bodies that identify differently, but not to female bodies that identify as 'men'.


Valentina Petrillo, born Fabrizio, visually impaired athlete Class of 1973, since January 2019 (age 45) she has been undergoing 'hormone therapy' and has been competing in women's races since 2020.

In a recent Fanpage interview stated about her results 'Valentina doesn't always win, unfortunately' and 'it is not necessarily the case that a former man has an advantage over a woman', he spoke of the titles he has already won in men's competitions and the records he holds, while a year ago on Rai1 had given as proof of fairness 'having lost 12 seconds in the 400 metres' and feeling absolutely equal to the athletes in the starting blocks.

To see more clearly, let us analyse the 'pre-transition' times and records in the men's 400 metre category and then the 'post-transition' times and records in the women's category.

Table 1 - Italian and world men's records in the outdoor 400 metres flat, absolute, masters M45 and paralympic T12/13.

Record 400m MElite - AbsoluteAge category -Master M45
World Athletics
Fispes T12/T13
International Paralympic  
51" 96
  F.Petrillo 56"67 (2018)  

This first table shows how much Petrillo's personal best in the 400m was far from all men's records, both in comparison with the record of the M45 masters peers and with the Italian Paralympic low vision T12/T13 record, a time slower by more than 6 and 4 seconds respectively, equal to +12.7% and 9.1%, useful percentages for later comparisons.

Table 2 - Italian and world women's records in the outdoor 400 metres flat, absolute, masters F45 and paralympic T12/13.

Record 400m FElite - AbsoluteAge category -Master F45
World Athletics
Fispes T12/T13
International Paralympic  
  V.Petrillo 58"57** (2022)  

*previous record

**From early 2021 Petrillo runs in the T13 instead of T12 visually impaired category, the records are a single T12/T13 category for FISPES

The post-2020 personal best is only 3.4% slower than the previous record (about two seconds, not 12 seconds difference) and the Italian master's record F45 is only a few tenths of a second away (+0.5%) while the Paralympic record has been improved by about 3 seconds (-4.7%).

The strong anomaly of the two personal bests (2018 and 2022) is also corroborated by the quantitative evaluation awarded by Fidal score, the higher the score the more prestigious the performance, the leap is evident, from 476 points as Fabrizio to 815 points as Valentina. As a comparison, in the Fidal scoring tables a woman scores 476 points with a time of 1:08"31 (here yes 12 seconds more than 56").

I record rubati di Petrillo: “Ma vincevo anche da uomo”. È vero? Ecco i fact-checking
From Fabrizio to Valentina the performance slows down by about 2 seconds, however 'Valentina's' performance in the women's category is rated more points (source: Fidal).

A comparison of male and female records over the distance (Absolute, Master45, T12/13) gives an average difference between the sexes of 14.7% (range 10.6%-18.3%). Petrillo in the passage recorded advantages in all comparisons analysed (see the anomalous slope of the segment in the graph that brings it into the record 'bubble'), advantages of between 8.7 and 13.8 percentage points, with an average of 11.6 percentage points. (Percentage points means the difference between percentages, e.g. +10% to -5% gives an advantage of 15 percentage points).

I record rubati di Petrillo: “Ma vincevo anche da uomo”. È vero? Ecco i fact-checking
Graph - Comparison of men's and women's 400m, world, Italian, masters and Paralympic T12/13 records and Petrillo's 'pre-transition' and 'post-transition' personal bests

Based on the analysed times the physical advantage appears to be largely preserved and we cannot exclude that part of the slowdown is due to the age factor (44 to 48 years).

Regarding the national titles obtained 'pre-transition' the information is correct, there are about ten titles obtained in both outdoor and indoor championships between 2016 and 2018, on the 100, 200 and 400 metres, however they are only in the Fispes Paralympic sphere (T12) unlike later on with Fidal master national titles, therefore against athletes of the same age and able-bodied (master titles: Arezzo 2020, Rieti 2021, Ancona indoor 2022, etc).

When Petrillo states that he now holds 5 out of 6 Italian records in the T13 sprint races (200m-400m, indoor and outdoor, 60m indoor) he is telling the truth, but this is further evidence of the unfair advantage he has acquired because there are no 'pre-transition' records among men.

As a further point of comparison, Fabrizio Petrillo's 56"67 was more than six seconds slower than the last-place finisher in the 400m T13 final in Rio 2016 (see here), now as Valentina her 58"57 recorded in Imola on 23 June could be enough to qualify for the final in Paris 2024 when she will be 50 years old (in Tokyo 2020 the time for entering the final was 58"48, the average age of the eight finalists was 24, see here).

This transition from unimportant athlete to potential Olympic participant is reminiscent in several respects of the Will/Lia Thomas affair, with a slow 2.6% on the 200-yard freestyle went from 462nd place in the men's rankings to 1st in the women's (the men's and women's times here have a differential of approximately 12%, see here). Thanks to the new rules of FINA, the International Swimming Federation, Thomas is no longer eligible for women's competitions as category changes are no longer allowed after puberty/12 years of age, thus wisely shifting the criterion back to biological sex and not perceived gender identity.


Those who defend women's sport are countered by those who ensure that competition is regular because athletes who identify as transgender do not always win in women's competitions. This argument is misleading and easy to dismantleFor example, starting before the start given by the starter or using doping substances does not guarantee victory but is nevertheless prohibited because it represents an unfair advantage. Then there is also the risk - difficult to prove, but real - that an athlete wishing to conceal the advantage gained from the change of category may underperform.

If rules are built on the unscientific assumption of no advantage, the risk is to slide towards two categories, one dominated by the strongest (male) athletes, the other pitting modest athletes against the best female athletes.

Having ascertained at several levels that women's sport must remain women-only for the sake of fairness, a solution can be found so that everyone can participate in sport. One way forward, proposed by Linda Blade in her book 'Unsporting', is to provide two categories: a women-only category (XX) and an open men's category, in which male athletes who identify themselves as women can compete.

To the objection raised that transgender people would be uncomfortable in a category they do not feel is their own, it should be noted that in several cases female athletes who declare themselves to be transgender participate in the category of their biological sex without any problems (see here).

It is not possible to ignore scientific evidence any longer and pretend not to see the unfair advantage of the order of 10% in a sport where even a single hundredth of a second counts. A women's category must be guaranteed both to avoid taking away the credibility of sporting values and even more so not to deprive female athletes of opportunities, victories and prizes that are theirs and theirs alone.

Note to readers: Any reports of inaccuracies, missing data or the like are appreciated.

Marco Alciator

Much of the news published by Feminist Post you will not read elsewhere. That is why it is important to support us, even with a small contribution: Feminist Post is produced solely by the voluntary work of many people and has no funding.
If you think our work can be useful for your life, we will be grateful for even the smallest contribution.

You can give us your contribution by clicking here: Patreon - Feminist Post
   - or -
Obligatory reason: FEMINIST POST
IBAN: IT80C0200812914000104838541
You might also be interested in
25 July 2022
Open field, closed lists
The tiger's eye does not want to see that you can reassemble and recombine the line-up all you want, but if the faces and names remain the same you have very little credibility. And if the only goal recognisable to most of the electorate is to bar the way for your political opponent - for once a woman, which makes it all the more surreal - your chances of success are not very good.
Work is in progress on the construction of the large rassemblement or open camp (the wide one has been discontinued). The discussion is only between men (with the partial exception of Emma Bonino) and the cement that holds the coalition project together is 'stopping Meloni': there is little discussion of political programmes, and what Calenda, Fratoianni and Di Maio may have in common is all to be understood. Observers and sociologists of politics scoff to point out that building a project 'against' [...].
Read now
20 July 2022
Where is the Casa delle Donne in Rome going?
'The House we are all' reads the beautiful slogan of the historic enclave in Trastevere. But in that space, which is public and should be open, the#039;agibility is only transfeminist. And after the uncritical support for the Zan ddl -to stop feminicides-, the yes to the 'uterus for rent' and to 'sex work', now also the hymn to male ultra-bodies in women sports: maybe it is time for a reflection
The International House of Women in Rome agrees with the University of Pennsylvania's proposal to name Lia Thomas 'Woman Athlete of the Year'. Lia Thomas, of whom we have spoken several times here, is the famous swimmer who has repeatedly beaten her opponents competing in the women's categories, but who has at least had the merit of finally exploding the issue of male ultra-athletes in women's sports. The post shared by the International House of Women, a confusing little treatise on intersectional feminism, [...].
Read now
5 July 2022
Mayor Beppe Sala's 'gift' to Pride
From now on, in Milan, the birth certificates of children of 'homogenous couples' will be automatically registered, including those born from surrogacy. Although the law and subsequent rulings firmly condemn the practice and point the way to 'adoption' for the 'intended' parent. But the registry office is the responsibility of the State, not of local administrations. And the Milanese have never been asked about it: all the critical aspects of a unilateral and very glamorous decision that could also present profiles of unconstitutionality
'We have restarted the recognition of children born in Italy by homogenous couples': the words with which Mayor Beppe Sala announced his personal 'gift' to Pride initially caused some confusion. In fact, children born 'in Italy' on the initiative of - and not 'by' - same-sex couples are only the children of women united with other women. The children of male couples are born in Canada, California or other procreative tourism destinations, but not in Italy [...].
Read now
29 June 2022
School ends, forced withdrawals of children begin again
Despite a recent ruling by the Supreme Court of Cassation defining the forced removal of minors as 'outside the rule of law', this morning in the province of Lodi an 11-year-old boy was snatched from his mother, who was forcibly and deceptively detained while her son was taken. Here is how the events unfolded in the account of a witness
This morning in the province of Lodi, in Casalmaiocco, an 11-year-old boy, Gioele, was forcibly snatched and suddenly and traumatically removed from the mother with whom he was living. Here are the facts as told by a MaternaMente activist present at the time: 'Deborah and her son had been summoned for a meeting by the social services this morning. The meeting took place online and the SS used reassuring tones. The mother then went to the municipality to [...].
Read now
20 June 2022
Bye bye 'Lia': world stop to trans swimmers in women's races
Despite the scandalous and opportunistic silence of the sports media, the World Swimming Federation closes to male bodies in women's competitions (something similar has also been decided for cycling). Soon, hopefully, all other categories will follow. The trophy-stealing 'Lia' Thomas cases will not happen again. Honour to the female athletes who fought against this colossal injustice. And to all of us who have resisted the misogynistic violence of gender ideology for years.
Fighting is needed: piece by piece the wall of trans-ideology is crumbling. And while the American Democrats - Hillary Clinton's word - are resoundingly distancing themselves from trans-activism because they realise that they are risking the presidency of the United States on these issues, the Fina (Fédération Internationale de Natation), the world governing body of swimming, has voted in favour of new rules according to which transgender athletes will not be allowed to compete in elite women's competitions if they have crossed any part of the [...]
Read now
11 June 2022
A letter to the editor of Repubblica. To explain to him what a woman is
Reactions from readers - and also readers - to Michela Marzano's unacceptable text according to which anyone is entitled to call herself a woman, and if a woman has something to object to, she is a TERF are multiplying. Here is Alessia Teani's open letter to Maurizio Molinari
Dear Director Maurizio Molinari, I take the liberty of writing to you directly because you have dared to call me a TERF from the pages of your newspaper. You said it to me, to my mother, to my good grandmothers. You have called my granddaughters, my pupils, my friends TERF. You, Mr. Molinari, are calling TERF to all the women who, upon entering the women's locker room, do not expect to see a naked man, with all the arrogance that your well-meaning [...]
Read now
1 2 3 ... 14