2 February 2023

Birth from a dead 'surrogate mother

A professor at the University of Oslo proposes using the bodies of women in irreversible comas, which can be damaged without ethical complications, to carry out pregnancies for others. But also men in a vegetative state (so feminists don't get angry) by grafting embryos into their livers. And children? Theme not considered
Please be aware that the translation of contents, although automatic, has a cost to Feminist Post but is provided to you without any charge. Please consider making a contribution via the "Support us" page if you intend to use our translation service intensively.
The contents of this site are translated using automatic translation systems without the intervention of professional translators.
Translations are provided for the sole purpose of facilitating reading by international visitors.
Share this article

It may have been inspirational Habla con ella, films by Pedro Almodovar in which the young dancer Alicia, in a coma after an accident, becomes pregnant by Benigno, the nurse who looks after her.

Anna Smajdor, Professor of Medical Bioethics University of Oslo, takes up and elaborates on a suggestion made in 2000 by Israeli researcher Rosalie Ber 'to circumvent the moral problems of gestational surrogacy' using women in a persistent vegetative state (PVS) as surrogates. The practice is called 'gestational whole-body donation'. (WBGD, whole-body gestational donation).

According to Smajdor, the WGBD "offers a alternative means of gestation for prospective parents who wish to have children but cannot or prefer not to gestate'. It would be a matter of considering "the possibility of donating one's whole body for gestational purposes just as some people donate parts of their bodies for organ donation. We already know that pregnancies can be successfully completed in brain-dead women. There is no obvious medical reason why such pregnancies would not be possible'.

The couple's embryos would be grafted into the uterus of the brain-dead woman which should therefore be properly ventilated and supported until their development.

Smajdor suggests 'using the framework for organ donation: "wherever organ donation is legal, WBGD with brain death would be a relatively simple modification.

Unlike Habla con ella "the pregnancy must not arise through 'natural' conception, in other words as a result of rape. "The commissioning parents might prefer creating an embryo for implantation using their own gametes or those of donors. So impregnation could be a surgical matter, preceded and followed by appropriate hormone therapy to ensure maximum chance of success'. 

The advantage is that "the pregnant woman is already dead and cannot be harmed. The commissioning parents can decide on abortion or selective reduction according to their own wishes, without having to worry about the effects on the pregnant woman'. Usually "We do not dare to transfer too many embryos into living women, because selective reduction is traumatic and harmful to the pregnant woman. There are no such problems in relation to the WBGD donor. Whether she needs more or less of a particular drug or whether fetal interventions are required, we will have none of the potential conflicts that may arise for ordinary pregnancies. Parents can transfer as many embryos as they can generate, maximising the chances of at least one viable birth and, if necessary, discarding damaged or diseased ones in advance'.

But there is more and better: WGBD mothers can also be men. In this way 'feminist concerns could be mitigated ... The prospect of a male pregnancy is not, as many would imagine, fanciful or science fiction. In 1999, Robert Winston told reporters that there were no inherent medical problems with the onset of a male pregnancy: the danger would be in childbirth. We already know that pregnancies can come to term outside the womb. The liver is a promising implantation site, thanks to its excellent blood supply. However, as Winston noted, this could be risky, even fatal, for the person carrying the pregnancy. But for brain-dead donors, the concept of 'fatal' is meaningless: the pregnant person is already dead. Therefore, even if the liver is irreparably damaged after gestation, this would not pose a problem if not to the extent that it might mean that pregnant males could only carry one pregnancy to term'.

"The prospect of the male gestant might therefore appease some feminists who might otherwise consider brain-dead gestation to be a step too far in the objectification of women's reproductive functions'.

What might be thought by those born to brain-dead mothers -because you have to tell them sooner or later, the right to the truth about one's origins is enshrined in international conventions; what becomes of that complex epigenetic relationship between the pregnant woman and the foetus, a true biochemical and sensory dialogue between the mother's body and that of the child; in short Professor Smajdor does not deal with all these other facets.

translation and adaptation by Marina Terragni, original article published here


Much of the news published by Feminist Post you will not read elsewhere. That is why it is important to support us, even with a small contribution: Feminist Post is produced solely by the voluntary work of many people and has no funding.
If you think our work can be useful for your life, we will be grateful for even the smallest contribution.

You can give us your contribution by clicking here: Patreon - Feminist Post
You might also be interested in
14 March 2023
Prefect to Mayor Sala: stop registering children of same-sex couples
The decision makes those girls and boys more equal and not unequal as we read in many ideological comments today. Starting with the equal right to the truth about one's origins enshrined in all international conventions. And to the attribution of the same rights of citizenship granted to every new born: that is why
The prefect of Milan has ordered the mayor Beppe Sala to block the transcription of birth certificates of children born by same-sex couples. For example, it will no longer be possible to fully transcribe birth certificates produced abroad - in Ukraine, Canada, California, etc. - by surrogacy, which also applies to heterosexual couples who have undertaken this practice. We radical feminists had appealed to the prefect to order Mayor Sala to respect the [...]
Read now
8 March 2023
Slavoj Žižek: puberty blockers are woke capitalism
The Marxist philosopher speaks of wokeness, the progressive cult of awareness and awakening, giving an evocative psychoanalytic reading of it. And warns that despite appearing under attack today we will have to deal with it for a long time to come
In an evocative article published by Compact, entitled Wokeness is here to stay -which we translate and partially reproduce here- the Marxist philosopher Slavoj Žižek tackles the subject of wokeness, the movement of 'awakening', analysing its critical aspects but also underlining the reasons why we will have to deal with it for a long time to come. Some argue that 'wokeness' is in decline. In reality it is gradually being normalised and conformed even by those who inwardly doubt it, and is practised by most academic institutions, [...].
Read now
3 March 2023
Transsexuality is not a lunch for genderqueers
Being transgender is not transgenderism but a deeply dramatic experience with an uncertain outcome. Which has nothing to do with the stale stereotypes with which gender identity is expressed. Neviana Calzolari's reflections
Republished courtesy of Dol's Magazine. Original article here Neviana Calzolari, sociologist, activist, writer and TV face. Yet hardly mainstream, indeed among the most acute (and critical) observers of the social-political landscape of our times (...) The I-Dee group of Milan and the Ipazia association of Catania met her. - The Zan bill was designed to combat homotranssphobia, therefore with good intentions,' Neviana began, 'despite this I remain sceptical about certain terminology, in particular 'gender identity', which alarms much of the world [...].
Read now
23 February 2023
Mental disorders in children: it's an epidemic. In parallel with the boom in 'gender dysphoria'
An American study reveals that psychological distress in adolescents has been on a growth spike since 2012 with different symptoms between males and females. And that almost always the idea of wanting to 'change sex' is accompanied by other problems. Loneliness, social networks, pornography: how savage marketing is destroying a generation
The silence on puberty blockers prescribed to girls and boys with gender non-conforming behaviour has finally been broken in Italy too. It has been broken mainly thanks to the efforts of radical feminists, parents' groups and Italian psychoanalysts who have written to the government (see here). The debate has also arrived on TV, with two recent episodes of Quarta Repubblica with interventions by Italian and foreign experts, from feminists Marina Terragni (here, from 1'46'') and Monica Ricci [...].
Read now
24 January 2023
The problem is not rooming-in but the loneliness of mothers
After the sad story of the baby who died next to his mother at the Pertini in Rome, for some the solution is to keep the babies in the nurseries and not in the room. But rooming-in was strongly advocated by women who used to be separated from their babies in hospital. It is, if anything, a question of allowing new mothers to have a spouse or wife to assist them. Especially in times of understaffing
Starting with the very painful case of the newborn baby who died at the Pertini hospital in Rome -probably by accidental suffocation, the judiciary will ascertain the causes: it could also be 'cot death' or something else- many and many conclude that rooming-in is a dangerous and wrong practice and that babies should stay in nurseries. I remember, however, that in the past women fought hard for rooming-in and for more than obvious reasons: not to be separated from the newborn after the long cohabitation [...].
Read now
24 January 2023
Sex and gender: JK Rowling's essay
In her text, the writer explains in detail the reasons why she felt the need to address the trans issue, defying the violence of activists. A manifesto-writer for gender critical feminism translated into Italian by Alessandra Asteriti
Attacking JK Rowling can now also be a business. The latest initiative is that of a young Canadian imbecile art book creator who has decided to de-rowling Harry Potter by publishing a special edition of the saga on the cover of which the author's name disappears: $170 per copy for a despicable abuse of power. Let him keep all the copies in stock. Back to the serious stuff: in June 2020 JK Rowling published an essay on her website detailing her position [...].
Read now
1 2 3 ... 19