4 October 2022

US, gay couple sues: surrogacy is a 'right', must be paid for by health insurance

The two men's claim aims to have the fact that they do not have a womb recognised as a 'disability': an absurd, envious and revealing claim. If they win in court all over America insurance companies and employers would have to reimburse gestations for other for men
Please be aware that the translation of contents, although automatic, has a cost to Feminist Post but is provided to you without any charge. Please consider making a contribution via the "Support us" page if you intend to use our translation service intensively.
The contents of this site are translated using automatic translation systems without the intervention of professional translators.
Translations are provided for the sole purpose of facilitating reading by international visitors.
Share this article

A gay couple initiated a lawsuit in New York labour court demanding that the employer-provided insurance pay for all the costs of the surrogacy instead of them, in order to ensure 'equal access to fertility treatment'. For all intents and purposes, a gay male couple is required by law to become a protected category as they both lacked a uterus and had no access to a uterus.

If they win their case, surrogacy only for gay male couples would become the responsibility of health insurance companies or employers throughout the US.

The Guardian, in a lengthy article on the affair, describes the couple as follows: 'Corey Briskin and Nicholas Maggipinto met in law school in 2011, got engaged in 2014 and announced their marriage in 2016 on the New York Times. They moved into a waterfront apartment building in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, with a bright family game room on the ground floor'.

The couple tells of having learned the costs of a biological child through surrogacy during an appointment with a fertility doctor provided by the organisation Gay Parents to Be (Future gay parents), advertised on Instagram. "Maggipinto takes 15 minutes to explain to me all the expenses they would have to incur if they tried to have a child genetically related to one of their own. The end result? "At least two hundred thousand dollars" says, tapping his index finger on the table with every word in disbelief,' writes the journalist of the Guardian.

"They could not afford it. Maggipinto receives a lawyer's salary at a large firm, but is burdened with student debt. Briskin worked for the city of New York as an assistant district attorney, earning about $60,000 per year. His job benefits included generous health insurance. But when they read the policy have discovered that they are the only category of people excluded from IVF (in vitro fertilisation). Infertility was defined as the inability to have a child through heterosexual sex or intrauterine insemination. This meant that heterosexuals and lesbians working for the city of New York would be able to cover the costs of IVF, but gay couples would never be able to benefit from it'.

"Briskin and Maggipinto then presented a class action complaint to the US Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) against the city of New York, suing Briskin's former employers for unlawful discrimination in the workplace. If they win, employers and health insurers across the US will be forced to change their policies to give homosexual males the same access to fertility benefits as everyone else.".

In essence, the couple claims that the city's insurance policy discriminates against them because, if they were two women or if they were in a heterosexual relationship, 'they would have access to the IVF benefits to which city employees are entitled'.

USA, coppia gay fa causa: l'utero in affitto è un "diritto", va pagato dall'assicurazione sanitaria
American feminist Phyllis Chesler

The American feminist Phyllis Chesler summarises the story as follows: 'They protest against the 'injustice' of not being born biologically female. Although they are both educated and affluent white men, they denounce the 'discrimination' due to the accident of their birth, which, despite their educational, economic, social, legal and sporting privilege, seek to have the 'disabled' or protected class declared. They also claim the 'right to fertility' of gay males'.

"I guess, to some extent, womb envy may play a role in the demand for a so-called 'reproductive justice' for gay men,' Chesler continues. In fact, 'while women without male partners (singles and lesbians) can access relatively low-tech assistance to reproduce, men without female partners need to resort to surrogacy to achieve exclusive genetic parenting.

And so, gay men now want insurance companies to treat the fact of being born male as a disability or as a protected category, claiming compensation. They are concerned that the money and legal power of gay men may override the rights of children, egg donor women and birth mothers, who do not have equivalent economic or political power."

Full article here. Here Phyllis Chesler's essay.

Translation by Maria Celeste


Much of the news published by Feminist Post you will not read elsewhere. That is why it is important to support us, even with a small contribution: Feminist Post is produced solely by the voluntary work of many people and has no funding.
If you think our work can be useful for your life, we will be grateful for even the smallest contribution.

You can give us your contribution by clicking here: Patreon - Feminist Post
   - or -
You can send to: ASSOCIAZIONE CULTURALE BLU BRAMANTE
Obligatory reason: FEMINIST POST
IBAN: IT80C0200812914000104838541
You might also be interested in
7 November 2022
Belgium, new feminicide law. To be studied
In Europe, male violence is the leading cause of death for women between the ages of 16 and 44. Belgium equips itself with a new law that for the first time legally defines feminicides in order to develop policies based on official statistics. Keeping in mind that violence is a device of male domination
Stop the slaughter of women. This is the meaning of the new 'law on the prevention of and fight against feminicides, gender-based crimes and the violence that precedes them' adopted at first reading in the Council of Ministers on 25 October in Belgium. Deposed by the Secretary of State for Gender Equality, Sarah Schlitz (Ecolo/Verdi), the framework law for the first time legally defines feminicides in order to develop combat policies based on official statistics. And in [...]
Read now
27 October 2022
England: new guidelines for 'trans' minors
While Spain is about to approve the horrifying Ley Trans, which allows the transition of girls from the age of 12 even if their parents oppose it, the English health service closes once and for all with the so-called pharmacological 'affirmative approach' (puberty blockers) practised for years and points to psychological treatment as the priority route. And in Italy? For the Italian Society of Paediatrics, these drugs do not cause any problems and their effects are completely 'reversible', a fact denied by several studies
The English health service (NHS) has published a new draft of guidelines for the treatment of children with gender dysphoria (full text here), pending the results of the Cass Review, an independent enquiry commissioned by the British health minister and led by paediatrician Hilary Cass (see here), which will lead to a complete restructuring of services dedicated to gender non-conforming children. After the closure of the Tavistock clinic -which we told you about here-, NHS puts a definitive end to the so-called [...]
Read now
21 October 2022
Women-containers: pro-life and pro-utero for hire see eye to eye
For one and the other, the female body must make itself available to 'produce' the unborn child by renouncing the possibility of choice once pregnancy has begun. But a new life only really begins when there is a maternal yes: a fact that is unattainable and unattainable by law. Otherwise the only possibility is compulsion.
At least three things can be said about the bill filed by Maurizio Gasparri to amend Article 1 of the Civil Code and introduce into our legal system the recognition of the legal capacity of the conceived 'with the intention of preventing voluntary abortion in any form, whether legal or clandestine'. The first: it is highly unlikely that the bill will reach parliamentary halls. The immediate consequence of its approval would be the substantial inapplicability of law 194 because abortion would in fact be tantamount to murder. None of the majority forces [...]
Read now
6 October 2022
'Destroy women's rights': JK Rowling against the Scottish premier and her trans law
As in Spain, feminism in Scotland fights against a law wanted by First Minister Nicola Sturgeon introducing gender self-determination without any medical diagnosis and lowering the age for access to 16. And this time too, the Harry Potter author stands by women, girls and children
JK Rowling takes a photo of herself wearing a t-shirt that reads 'Nicola Sturgeon, destroyer of women's rights' to support women protesting in front of the Scottish Parliament against the controversial gender recognition reform bill wanted by Scotland's First Minister. Activists from For Women Scotland gathered in front of the Scottish Parliament this morning for a demonstration against the bill promoted by Sturgeon, which would make gender self-determination easier - we have [...]
Read now
5 October 2022
The Iranians are fighting for us too
Women in Iran are oppressed, violated and killed precisely because of their bodies as women. And their revolt could free everyone and everyone. Is'the woke West of'gender identity and 'freedom of the veil' ready to understand and support this revolution that blows for us too? Woman, life, freedom
In the uncertain and ever-changing geopolitical order of our time, in the midst of a global political agenda that from right to left forgets women, betraying, albeit in different ways, female exclusivity and the richness of sexual difference, the struggle of Iranian women has something epic, something moving. The killing of Mahsa Amini shows how the issue of the 'veil as freedom' is the quintessence of intellectual dishonesty, of logical fallacy, of an age-old lie. To 22-year-old Mahsa, the desire to 'feel the [...]
Read now
24 September 2022
SPAIN: SOCIALISTS AGAINST THE TRANS LEY
Unlike their Italian counterparts from the PD and the left who stand for free gender identity, the Spanish progressives break with the PSOE's transactivist policies in defence of women and children. In their manifesto the excellent arguments against what, if passed, could be the worst transactivist law in the world
Breaking with its party, the PSOE, and sending a signal to the women of the European left, who are generally aligned in defence of transactivist diktatism, the Federación de Mujeres Progresistas launches a courageous manifesto against the Trans Law wanted by the governing majority in Spain (PSOE and Podemos) and being approved by an emergency procedure, without an effective parliamentary debate or a wide public discussion. The initiative also comes in response to the clamorous break between historical Spanish feminism -united in the Contraborrado cartel- [...].
Read now
1 2 3 ... 28