Hanna Barnes is a BBC journalist. After conducted a thorough investigation into the Tavistock clinic in London, a center for the gender transition of minors, and after having discovered the flaws of that service, he decided to make a book out of it. But it wasn't at all easy to find a publisher willing to publish it. Not because Barnes' work wasn't documented and rigorous, but because no publishing house could withstand the probable accusation of transphobia that the publication of the book would have entailed: apparently today in the West this is the most terrifying thing, it is difficult to find someone willing to get into trouble. In the end a publisher (Swift Press) found his book. Second The Times, “Time to Think: The Inside Story of the Collapse of the Tavistock's Gender Service for Children” is among the best books coming out in 2023. Also the Financial Times lists it among the books not to be missed this year.
The Sunday Times devoted extensive reporting to Barnes' work. Here are some excerpts from the article.
It wasn't easy for Hannah Barnes to publish her book. As an investigative producer for Newsnight, a long-serving analytical journalist and documentarian, she is used to covering intricate stories and this one in particular, she knew better than anyone, was complex. Since 2019 he was responsible for the Gender Identity Development Service (Gids) based at the Tavistock and Portman NHS Foundation Trust in North London, the only one of its kind for children in England and Wales, and decided to write a book about it. “I wanted to write a definitive account of what happened because there's a need for it,” he says. Not everyone agreed. “None of the big publishing houses would accept it,” they told me. “It is interesting that there were no negative responses to the proposal. They simply said, “We couldn't convince the younger members of our staff.” “
Whatever their objections, they could not have addressed the quality of Barnes' book –Time to Think: The Inside Story of the Collapse of the Tavistock's Gender Service for Children– is an in-depth and scrupulously non-judgmental account of the collapse of the NHS, based on hundreds of hours of interviews with ex-doctors and patients. It also offers a stunning insight into failure: failure of leadership, child protection and the NHS (…)
Gids treats children and young people who express confusion – or dysphoria – about their gender identity, meaning they believe their biological sex does not reflect who they are. Since the service was commissioned nationally by the NHS in 2009, he has curated thousands of children helping many of them to access gonadotropin-releasing hormone agonists, known as “puberty blockers”, originally formulated to treat prostate cancer, castrate sex abusers and is also used to treat endometriosis and fertility issues. The service will close this spring, following a deeply critical report published in February 2022 by Dr Hilary Cass, a highly respected pediatrician who was commissioned to review the service by NHS England. Cass concluded that “a fundamentally different service model is needed.”
Gids should be an easy story to tell: many people have been trying to make disclosures for a long time, but Anna Hutchinson, a clinical psychologist who worked at the Tavistock Centre, told Barnes that those who spoke out were "always repelled in one way or another". other".
“It's really not normal for mental health professionals to speak openly with journalists like they spoke to me, and it shows how desperate they were in their attempt to get the story out." says Barnes. Doctors fought to be heard just as Barnes later fought to get his book out; some people prefer censorship to the truth if the latter conflicts with their ideology. Nevertheless, concerns about service had been in plain sight for years: In February 2019, a 54-page report compiled by Dr David Bell, then a consultant psychiatrist at the trust and staff governor, was leaked to Sunday Times. Dr Bell said Gids was providing “woefully inadequate” care to its patients and that its staff had “ethical concerns” about some of the practices of the service, how to give access to puberty blockers to 'very disturbed and distressed' children. Gids, he concluded, is “not fit for purpose”. Many of Bell's concerns had been expressed 13 years earlier in a 2006 report on Gids by Dr David Taylor – then medical director of trust – which described the long-term effects of puberty blockers as “untested and unstudied”.
“Taylor's recommendations were largely ignored,” Barnes writes, and in the decade and a half between the Taylor and Bell reports, Gids reportedly referred more than 1,000 children for puberty blocking, some as young as nine. It is impossible to get a precise number because neither the service nor the endocrinologists who prescribe the blockers have been able to provide them to those who have requested them, including Barnes. One figure they admitted was that between 2014 and 2018, 302 children aged 14 and under were reported for blockers. It is generally accepted now that puberty blockers affect bone density and potentially cognitive and sexual development. “It was all there, everything. But the lessons have not been learned,” Barnes says.
As this story touches on gender identity – one of the most sensitive topics of our time – it was difficult to overcome the ideological battles to show the truth. Was the service helping children to become themselves, as its defenders claimed? Or was pathologizing and medicalizing unhappy children and adolescents, as others claimed?
This reflects the partisan way people view gender dysphoria: Is this similar to being gay and therefore something to celebrate? or is it an expression of self-loathing, such as an eating disorder, that requires therapeutic intervention? This has led to the current confusion over whether the planned ban on conversion therapy should include gender in addition to sexuality. “Conversion therapy” obviously sounds terrible, and politicians across the spectrum – from Crispin Blunt on the right to Nadia Whittome on the left – have loudly expressed their support for including gender in the bill, which would therefore suggest that therapy for gender dysphoria is analogous to trying to “cure” someone of homosexuality.
But many clinicians argue that including gender would potentially criminalize psychotherapists who explore with their patients the reason for their confusion (…)
How come the only NHS clinic for children with gender dysphoria didn't realize what it was doing? or did he continue to do so? Thanks to Barnes and his book, we now know the answers to these questions and many more.
Gids was founded in 1989 by Domenico Di Ceglie, an Italian child psychiatrist. Its aim was to create a place where young people could talk about their gender identity with “non-judgmental acceptance”. Puberty blockers were available to 16-year-olds who wanted to “pause time” before committing – or not – to gender reassignment surgery (…) In the early 2000s those working within Gids noted that some gender activist groups – such as Mermaids, which supports “gender diverse” children and their families – were exerting an “astonishing” influence on Gids, especially regarding encouraging the prescription of puberty blockers. Barnes writes in his book that Sue Evans, a nurse who was working at Gids at the time, asked a senior managers so that Gids could not focus only on verbal therapy and not administer drugs that alter the body. According to her and another doctor, Barnes writes, the senior managers he replied: “It's because we have this treatment here that people come.”
Around the year 2000, the trust he asked Di Ceglie to draw up a report on who his patients were. The results were surprising. Most of Gids' patients were boys with an average age of 11 years. More than 25% of them had spent time in therapy, 38% came from families with mental health problems and 42% had lost at least one parent, either through separation or death. Most had other problems such as anxiety and trauma from physical abuse; almost a quarter had a history of self-harm. No conclusions were drawn and Gids continued to treat gender dysphoria as a cause rather than a symptom of adolescent distress.
Was a gender identity clinic in the Netherlands who came up with the idea of giving blockers to children under 16 in the late 1990s, and in doing so provided Gids with the justification he needed. The Dutch clinic said 12-year-olds could be treated with blockers if they had suffered from gender dysphoria for a long time, were psychologically stable and lived in a supportive environment. This was known as the “Dutch Protocol”. Advocacy groups and some gender specialists have encouraged the clinic to follow suit.
Dr Polly Carmichael took over the directorship of Gids in 2009 and, in 2011, the service undertook an “early intervention study” to examine the effect of blockers on under-16s, because so little was known about their impact on children. Rather than wait for the study results, Gids removed all age restrictions on blockers in 2014, allowing children as young as nine to access them. At the same time the requests were increasing dramatically, which meant that doctors had less time to evaluate patients before helping them access blockers. In 2009 Gids had 97 requests. In 2020 there were 2,500, with another 4,600 on the waiting list, and doctors were desperately overstretched. “As the numbers seeking Gids' help exploded around 2015, there was growing pressure to overcome them. In some cases this meant shorter and less in-depth evaluations.
Doctors saw increasingly mentally ill children, including those who identified not only as a different gender but also as different nationalities and ethnicities: “Usually East Asian, Japanese, Korean, that sort of thing,” says Dr. Matt Bristow, a former Gids clinician. But this was seen by Gids as irrelevant for their gender identity issues. Even the past stories of sexual abuse were ignored: “In the case of a girl being abused by a male, I think a question to ask is whether there is any relationship between identifying as male and feeling safe,” Bristow says. But, doctors point out, any concerns raised with their superiors always got the same response: that the children should be referred to blockers unless they specifically said they didn't want them. And few guys said it.
Then there was the number of autistic and same-sex attracted children who attended the clinic saying they were transgender. Fewer than 2% children in the UK are thought to have an autism spectrum disorder; at Gids, However, more than a third of their contacts had moderate to severe autistic traits. “Some staff feared they would be needlessly treating autistic children,” Barnes writes.
There were similar fears about gay children. Doctors recall multiple cases of young people who had suffered homophobic bullying at school or at home, and then identified as trans. According to clinician Anastassis Spiliadis “in many cases” a family says: “Thank God my child is trans and not gay or lesbian”. Girls say, “When I hear the word 'lesbian' I cringe,” and boys have spoken to doctors about their disgust at being attracted to other boys. When in 2012 Gids asked the teenagers who had turned to the service news regarding their sexuality, over 90% of females and 80% of males stated that they were attracted to the same sex or bisexual. Bristow came to believe that Gids was performing “conversion therapy for gay children” and there was a macabre joke among the team that “they wouldn't stay gay anymore at the rate Gids was going.” When gay doctors like Bristow expressed their concerns to those in charge, they said it was implied that they were not objective because they were gay and therefore "too involved."
What if becoming trans was – for some people – a way to convert from being gay? If a boy is attracted to other boys but is ashamed of it, then one potential way around the problem is to identify as a girl and then insist that he is heterosexual. This possibility complicates the government's plan – which has cross-party support – to include gender alongside sexuality in the bill to ban conversion therapy, given that allowing a young person to change gender is sometimes in itself a form of conversion therapy (…)
Also the sex ratio was changing to a notable extent. When Di Ceglie started her gender clinic, the vast majority of her patients were boys with an average age of 11, and many had been suffering from gender distress for a long time. But as early as 2019-20, girls outnumbered boys at Gids by six to one in some age groups, particularly between 12 and 14 years old, and most had not suffered from gender dysphoria until after the onset of puberty (…)
The doctors knew that their patients were not like those in the Dutch protocol. Those patients had been subjected to screening, had suffered from gender dysphoria since childhood and were psychologically stable, with no other mental health problems. “Gids instead – according to almost every doctor I spoke to – referred to people under 16 for puberty blockers who did not meet those conditions,” Barnes writes. Most children aged 11 to 15 who attended the clinic between 2010 and 2013 were placed on blockers. Doctors tried to reassure themselves that the blockers were only giving their patients time to think about what they wanted by easing their distress. But in 2016 the Gids research team presented the initial results of its early intervention study, which examined the effect of prescribing blockers to children under 16: although the children said they were “very satisfied” with their treatment, their mental health and gender-related distress remained the same or worsened. AND each of them had switched to sex hormones cross-sex: synthetic testosterone for female births, estrogen for male births. Rather than giving them time to think, the blockers seemed to put them on the path to surgery. Doctors were concerned that the service had abandoned NHS best practice. They have repeatedly raised the issue with Carmichael and the executive team, but nothing has changed. In just six months in 2018, 11 people who worked at Gids left for ethical reasons. The people who spoke, such as David Bell and Sonia Appleby, the child protection officer for the Tavistock Trust, say they were bullied or fired (…)
Everything the whistleblowers tried to say was confirmed. A 2020 inspection by Gids' Care Quality Commission rated the service 'inadequate' and pointed out that some evaluations for puberty blockers consisted of only “two or three sessions” and that some staff “did not feel able to raise concerns without fear of retaliation.” Around the same time, Gids' former patient, Keira Bell, has launched a judicial review against the trust, claiming that at 16 she was too young to understand the repercussions of being placed on blockers and that she bitterly regretted her transition (…)
So what really happened to Gids? And why didn't anyone stop him? Barnes' book suggests multiple credible factors. External activist groups, such as Mermaids and Gendered Intelligence, came to exert undue influence on the service and they complained if they felt things weren't being done their way. For example, Gendered Intelligence complained to Carmichael, the director of Gids, when a doctor dared to publicly express the opinion that not all children with gender dysphoria would become transgender. In 2016, an expert in gender reassignment surgery warned Gids that subjecting boys to puberty blockers made it harder for them to undergo surgery as adults because their penises had not developed enough for surgeons to construct genitalia feminine. Instead, surgeons had to use “segments of the intestine” to create a “neo-vagina.” But senior managers refused doctors' requests to write it in a leaflet for patients and families. In the book, Hutchinson is quoted as saying: “I could be wrong, but I think Polly [Carmichael] was afraid to write things down in case they ended up in the hands of Mermaids” (…)
Money is suspected to have been another issue. When Gids joined the Tavistock Trust it was a secondary service, it wasn't even in the main building. But in 2020-21 gender services accounted for about a quarter of the revenue of trust (…)
“It's really surprising how few people were willing to question Gids. As one doctor told me, since it was about gender there was this "veil of mystery". There was a sense of, “Oh, it's about gender, so we can't ask the same questions we would ask any other part of the NHS.” For example: Is it safe? Where is the evidence? Where is the data?
And then there was the external culture. The failure of basic safeguarding at Gids appears to have accelerated from 2014 onwards, at the same time as there was a push for the rights of transgender people. Stonewall, after having contributed to guaranteeing equal marriage for gays, had now turned its attention to the rights of trans people (...) Television networks also had their say (…)
David Bell suggests that the Tavistock Trust protected Gids “because they saw it as a way of showing that we weren't grumpy old Tories; that we were ahead of the game and ahead of the curve.” The fact that the Tavistock Clinic was briefly, in the 1930s, a place where homosexual men were taken to be "cured" probably also played a role in the country's embrace of gender ideology. trust, as if it were an atonement for a wrong past.
According to Dr. Cass' suggestions, Gids will close this spring and be replaced with regional centers, where young people will be seen by doctors with multiple specialties (…) It seems incredible that such a disaster could have happened. How an NHS service was able to medicalise so many autistic and same-sex attracted young people, teenage girls and unhappy children who simply felt uncomfortable with male or female role models, with so little knowledge of the causes of their distress or the effects of medicine ? And how did Carmichael, still director of Gids, face no repercussions, while those who tried to report claimed they were bullied and fired? On the other hand, it is a miracle that the information is available now. For too long too many people have turned a blind eye to problems arising from gender ideology, including healthcare for children with gender dysphoria – as they have focused on trying to be on the right side of history and refused to look to obvious wrongs.
Barnes knows some will be mad at her for writing the book. But he also knows he had to write it. “Even among doctors working on the front lines of this issue there is no consensus on the best way to care for these children. There needs to be a debate that needs to come out of the clinic and be developed in society because it's not just about trans people. It's much more than that. It's about the kids.”
Translation by Marina Terragni
Original article here
This article is produced through voluntary work.
Much of the news you read here you won't find in any other media.
If you think our work is useful, thank you if you can support us.
Even the smallest contribution is precious!

