Self-ID and the prison system: men in women's prisons. A report from Canada

Please be aware that the translation of contents, although automatic, has a cost to Feminist Post but is provided to you without any charge. Please consider making a contribution via the "Support us" page if you intend to use our translation service intensively.
The contents of this site are translated using automatic translation systems without the intervention of professional translators.
Translations are provided for the sole purpose of facilitating reading by international visitors.
Share this article

An Irish newspaper,, reports today la news of a woman arrested in Dublin for possession of violent child pornography images. Only at the end of the article it says, almost incidentally, that it is a man who identifies himself as a woman. In countries that allow the self-id -the self-certification of gender- if a prisoner claims to be a woman they can be transferred to a women's prison. This involves very serious risks for the safety and dignity of female prisoners. This is what happens in Canada, where, since 2017, a law has authorised self-id.

On 7 March, a group of Canadian women gathered outside the Grand Valley Institution for Women, a women's prison in Ontario, to protest against the transfer of male prisoners who claim to feel like women.

Transfers of men to women's prisons happen regularly in Canadain the general silence since the entry into force in 2017 of the gender identity' law which allows you to change gender with a simple self-declaration (self-id). It means that a male prisoner can declare himself a woman, without any medical diagnosis or intervention, and ask to be transferred to a women's prison. Most of them have committed homicides and sexual offences, and leaves a much quieter home and community circuit than the women's institution.

Of the 14 male prisoners transferred that we know of, 12 have not had surgery or taken female sex hormones.

The main voice in the defence of incarcerated women is Heather Mason. A former prisoner herself, Heather has seen the damage this policy does to vulnerable women, who have often already suffered a life of physical and sexual violence, poverty and alienation.

"We have fully discharged the risk of violence between inmates in male prisons on women", he said in his speech. "We are used as shields to protect men who self-identify as women from the violence of other men'.

Self-ID e sistema carcerario: uomini nelle prigioni femminili. Un resoconto dal Canada
Steve "Sam" Mehlenbacher. He raped an inmate at the Grand Valley Institution (see here)

Mason is speaking at her own personal risk (considering the nature of those she is trying to restrict - criminals and gender activists), and without the support of institutions that have historically fought for incarcerated women caught up in the ideology of 'gender identity'. The Canadian press is almost completely silent on this issue and reports on trans people only from a positive point of view. Since the federal prison agency, Correctional Services Canada, does not provide information on male prisoners transferring, Mason relies on a network of women, inside and outside prison, and ingenious detective work to find these men and what they have done.

Thanks to Mason's investigations, we learned that some of the most obvious risks of placing dangerous male prisoners with vulnerable women had already been realised: sexual and physical violence, pregnancy and sexually transmitted diseases. Women felt the need to arm themselves with makeshift means, such as cans of soup hidden in their socks.

There are also less obvious but equally unfair consequences for women, such as the re-traumatisation of victims of abuse, rivalries because of the added sexual element of being with an intact male, the loss of dignity and privacy that women retain when in monosexual spaces, etc. Services such as Mother and Child Programwhich humanely allows the child to stay with its mother, are at risk of being cancelled due to increased security measures necessary to supervise violent male criminals. Counselling services offered to women as rehabilitation are useless for male prisoners, who have different behaviour patterns (despite their supposed 'gender identity'), as evidenced by the crimes they have committed.

Female guards also are forced to deal with these men who identify themselves as women, for example during searches, and feel that their safety and dignity are being compromised. In fact, their union wants to arm the guards in the women's prison with more powerful guns and riot gear. This increase in the level of security is a direct result of the influx of dangerous male prisoners, and will have a negative effect on the female prison population.

The Correctional Services Canada accepted all this in the name of human rights and fairness to men. It is certainly not fair to the women who have to endure these unjust conditions in their captivity. Their human rights do not count in this equation. For women who identify themselves as men, no transfer to a male prison is allowed. The possibility of them being raped is too high.

The protest was organised by two groups created 'from below' to fight for women's rights in Canada, caWsbar (Canadian Women's Sex-based Rights) and We The Females. Ex-convicts and guards also joined the demonstration. Although media coverage was poor (e.g. here), there were no interruptions from gender activists, and many passers-by showed their support. After the success of the first protest at the GVI, the women held a second one on 20 March: the number of protesters increased, it was animated by songs and a group of crossing guards stopped and joined the women. We can only hope that the tide is turning for some of Canada's most marginalised women, made victims again by the prison system.

Tania Alessandrini for Feminist Post, 26 March 2021

Much of the news published by Feminist Post you will not read elsewhere. That is why it is important to support us, even with a small contribution: Feminist Post is produced solely by the voluntary work of many people and has no funding.
If you think our work can be useful for your life, we will be grateful for even the smallest contribution.

You can give us your contribution by clicking here: Patreon - Feminist Post
You might also be interested in
5 June 2023
Los Angeles: queer clubs on families
Fathers and mothers peacefully demonstrating against the Pride event held at their children's school - kindergarten and primary schools - were physically assaulted with fists and baseball bats by Lgbtq+ and Antifa activists. In California you can no longer decide anything about your children's education
The pictures you see come from Los Angeles, where last Friday a group of parents protested against an LGBTQ Pride event organised at school for kindergarten and primary schools children. A group of left-wing extremists arrived to disrupt the event and attacked the parents with baseball bats and fists, starting a violent brawl that ended only after the police intervened. On the eve of the 'PRIDE assembly' organised at the Saticoy [...]
Read now
4 June 2023
CIAMS, STOP SURROGACY NOW, FINRRAGE, LA JAPAN COALITION and other associations. And together with them such eminent figures of international feminism as SYLVIANE AGACINSKI, GENA COREA and PHYLLIS CHESLER. Who together with us are asking the Italian parliamentarians to approve the law that will pass the Chamber of Deputies on 19 June.
Rete per l'Inviolabilità del Corpo Femminile (Network for the Inviolability of the Female Body), Radfem Italia, and FINAARGIT (International Feminist Network Against Artificial Reproduction, Gender Ideology and Transhumanism) have always shared the goal of the universal abolition of the surrogate motherhood. Together we support the bill on surrogacy that will be debated in the Chamber of Deputies next 19 June, which extends the punishability of the practice even if it is carried out in a foreign country and which is a decisive step forward in the direction of universal abolition, offering -if approved- a model for other legislations [...].
Read now
30 May 2023
Spain: woke sex also among the reasons for the end of Podemos
Ley Trans. Only Yes is Yes' law that reduced penalties for sex offenders. And now also a Manifesto for Sex Education for All* that jeopardises the safety of girls and boys. The spirit is always the same: a queer sexuality promoted by outgoing minister Irene Montero. Which, however, voters and electors apparently do not like. An analysis by lecturer Juana Gallego, feminist affected by the cancel culture
In yesterday's local elections in Spain, the left lost disastrously - as in Italy, for that matter. In particular, there was the stinging defeat of Podemos, which in many regions almost went extinct. In the analyses of the Spanish vote, perhaps not enough emphasis is given to two manifesto-laws of Podemos, and in particular of the transfeminist minister Irene Montero: the 'Only Yes is Yes' law, which reduced penalties for sexual crimes, and the Ley Trans, which [...]
Read now
15 May 2023
Jama: when men give birth
In an incredible, recently published study, the American Medical Association's journal, one of the most important in the field, tries to give scientific backing to the idea that childbirth is not just a female experience. Because if it were exclusive, it would also be exclusionary. An operation on language in collision with reality
As we know, there are words that can no longer be used, especially in international scientific documents and studies. At the top of the list of tabooed words are all the terms that have to do with female difference understood as the exclusive possibility of giving birth to human beings, and thus: 'woman' -if biologically understood and not open to define persons not born women-, 'mother' and 'maternal', 'breast', with reference to breast-feeding, and so on. The operation on language aims to qualify [...].
Read now
13 May 2023
Legislation against violence against women should talk about sex and not 'gender identity': open letter to the European Parliament
Violence against women will not be combated if the texts of laws and treaties do not clearly refer to sex and not 'gender'. We join feminist and gender critical groups in an appeal to MEPs who will vote on the Commission's anti-violence proposal: write clearly in the text that women and girls are the female sex and leave no room for gender ideology
We, too, signed the letter to the European Commission on combating violence against women and domestic abuse drafted by WORIADS, a coalition of gender-critical citizens whose aim is to inform and raise awareness of the dangers of gender identity in the European institutions. The letter demands that European regulations on violence against women clearly recognise the category of biological sex. Below is the full text that will be sent to the members of the European Parliament who will vote on the [...].
Read now
8 May 2023
The Bundestag is preparing to vote on a proposal modelled on the horrible Spanish law that allows free choice of gender even for minors with a simple self-declaration at the registry office (in addition to the possibility of changing one's mind several times). Also in the front line here is a left-wing woman counterpart of Irene Montero: the Green Minister for Women's Affairs Lisa Paus. But the opinion of the Federal Constitutional Court, which expresses many doubts about the deletion of the category 'sex', will be needed.
What is a woman? The answer that Justice Minister Buschmann (FDP, Liberal Democratic Party) and Women's Affairs Minister Lisa Paus (Greens, pictured) give to this question is: a woman is anyone who claims to be a woman. This is the core of the 'bill on self-determination in gender registration' that both ministries have now presented. With a simple declaration at the registry office, everyone will in future be able to change their sex: from male to [...]
Read now
1 2 3 ... 45