Maya Forstater, fired for saying sex cannot be changed, wins in court: it was discrimination

Decisive for gender critical feminism around the world was the victory of Maya, a researcher who lost her job over a tweet in which she wrote that biological sex is immutable and that women have rights based on sex. Britain reaffirms the right to criticise gender identity: threats and accusations of transphobia are illegitimate. "A'further proof" says Forstater "that the wind is changing". The final ruling of the labour court also ordered the company that did not renew the contract of the researcher, co-founder of Sex Matters, to pay compensation. A triumph across the board
Please be aware that the translation of contents, although automatic, has a cost to Feminist Post but is provided to you without any charge. Please consider making a contribution via the "Support us" page if you intend to use our translation service intensively.
The contents of this site are translated using automatic translation systems without the intervention of professional translators.
Translations are provided for the sole purpose of facilitating reading by international visitors.
Share this article

A year ago, June 2021, Feminist Post published a article on case of Maya Forstater, the British researcher whose employment contract was not renewed by her employer for expressing critical views on the concept of gender identity and reaffirming the importance of women's gender-based rights. The article closed by reminding readers that Maya's case was not yet over, and although the labour court's appeal ruling had established that Maya's convictions were protected in principle by the Equal Opportunities Act, It remained to be established whether Maya had been the victim of discrimination based on her personal beliefs.

We are happy to announce that today the labour court agreed with Maya Forstater and recognised her treatment by her employer as discriminatory treatment under the law. A judgement will follow to determine the amount of compensation.

Below is the press release issued by Maya Forstater for further details on the judgment and its grounds.


6 July 2022. Maya Forstater, who had sued his employer, the Center for Global Development [Centre for Global Development, or CGD] for discrimination based on personal beliefs, won the case on the grounds expressed by the court that the employer's conduct amounted to unlawful discrimination, justification based on the protection of personal beliefs by English law.

This ruling follows the previous judgment of the Labour Court of June 2021, in which the court ruled, with binding effect, that Maya Forstater's personal convictions, so-called 'gender critical' (in essence criticism of the importance of gender identity in the context of women's rights) were protected by theEquality Act, i.e. equal opportunities legislation. The ruling did not end the litigation, which continued in the labour court to determine whether Maya Forstater had been the victim of discrimination based on her personal beliefs.

The court unanimously determined that the following actions of the employer CGD constituted discrimination based on personal beliefs:
1. La retraction of the offer of the employment contract;
2. The non-renewal of the fellowship;
3. The removal of the profile from the CGD website.

The court also ruled that Maya Forstater's tweets and comments, which were the motivation for Forstater's treatment by her employer, were legitimate expressions of her protected personal beliefs. Consequently, the negative reaction of the CGD is in this case as unlawful discrimination.

Maya Forstater, licenziata per aver detto che il sesso non si può cambiare, vince in tribunale: fu discriminazione
JK Rowling's support for Maya Forstater

Among the comments by Maya Forstater at the basis of the litigation include but are not limited to:
- 'A man's inner conviction that he is a woman has no material basis'.
- The description of Pips Bunce, a man who identifies as a woman only a few days a week, as a 'part-time transvestite'.
- The comparison between self-identified trans women and Rachel Dolezal [the white American woman who identifies as African American].
- "The places and situations where women and girls are sexually abused and harassed are part of the 'normality' in women's lives"; (said) in the context of a debate on the consequences for women's safety of recognising trans women as women. This comment was not, as argued by counsel for the CGD, 'an exaggeration' but simply 'an unexceptionable finding in the context of the debate ... [that] did not constitute an objectively unreasonable remark'.
- The description of gender self-identification (self-id) as 'a feeling conceived within the mind' did not equate gender identification with a mental illness and 'was no more than an expression of Forstater's personal beliefs about gender identity'.

The court also recognised Forstater's right to criticise those who held an opposing position to his, arguing that this right to criticise was legitimate. Specifically, the court recognised that if the expression of a personal belief is considered offensive, the offence is not sufficient to deprive that belief of the protection of the law. Expressions included the description of the other party's opinions as 'stupid, dangerous or unfair' and the statement that the access of male individuals to women-only spaces resulted in "increased risks and discomfort" for women.

Maya Forstater, researcher specialising in public policy[1] e founder of an organisation dedicated to human rights, Sex Matters[2]welcomed the court's ruling.

"My case concerns all those who believe in the importance of truth and freedom of expression.

"We are all free to believe what we want. This does not imply that we are free to force others to follow our beliefs, to deprive those who disagree of the right to express themselves or to force a person to deny reality.

"Human beings do not have the ability to change sex. This statement is not a hate crime; on the contrary, it is essential to allow every human being to be treated in a way that guarantees their safety and dignity. It should not require courage to state this truth, and one should not risk one's job for making this statement.

"I am pleased that the court has allowed me to make public the treatment I suffered at the Center for Global Development. The court ruled that I was a victim of discrimination based on my belief that biological sex is a real fact and of fundamental importance, and that this belief is shared by the majority of the population in this country (UK)]. I hope employers take note of this ruling.

"I want to thank my family, who have shared this experience with me these past three years, and my lawyers: Ben Cooper QC, Anya Palmer, and Peter Daly. But above all I want to thank the thousands of women and men who have shown me their support, and in particular JK Rowling, who stood by me in the darkest moments.

"Knowing that my case has helped other people find the courage to voice their dissent in the face of unfair and discriminatory practices in their employment has made it easier to overcome the difficulties of the past three years. Tall those who are fighting such battles - and there are many - have my solidarity and support.

"I also want to thank all those fantastic organisations fighting to protect women's rights. Thanks to them, the world will become a fairer and safer place for women and girls. These organisations have courageously taken over the place that much better-funded organisations, such as the CGD, have cowardly abandoned.

"The CGD's unfair treatment of me, and the prejudice shown towards those who believe that sex is a material reality, have changed my life. If my employer had not terminated my employment, I would never have contributed to the foundation of Sex Matters. I would never have the opportunity to be part of this incredible movement in my country fighting to reaffirm the importance of gender-based rights.

Women have had enough of being sidelined in language, law, public policy and public spaces. This ruling is further proof that the wind is changing."

Introduction and translation by Alessandra Asteriti

[1] Maya Forstater has worked for many years in the field of international development, specialising in taxation and sustainable development. Maya was a visiting fellow at the European headquarters of the Center for Global Development, a Washington-based think-tank, between 2017 and 2019, when he lost his job in March 2019 after publicly speaking out against changes to the Gender Transition Act (Gender Recognition Act of 2004), changes later abandoned by the UK government.

[2] Maya Forstater is Executive Director of Sex Matters, a non-profit organisation co-founded by Forstater in 2021 to promote gender-based women's rights. Sex Matters promotes greater legislative clarity on gender-based rights, with regard to women's services, schools, sports and freedom of expression.

Much of the news published by Feminist Post you will not read elsewhere. That is why it is important to support us, even with a small contribution: Feminist Post is produced solely by the voluntary work of many people and has no funding.
If you think our work can be useful for your life, we will be grateful for even the smallest contribution.

You can give us your contribution by clicking here: Patreon - Feminist Post
You might also be interested in
20 September 2023
UK, you can no longer say 'woman' or 'mother': woke provisions of the General Medical Council
Decision of unprecedented violence by the British Medical Register: the word woman must be deleted at every level. It cannot even be mentioned when discussing motherhood, childbirth, breastfeeding, menopause. Even 999, the emergency number, can no longer ask what sex the person asking for help is. The woke know very well that the female body is the main obstacle to the transhuman project. And they want to erase it even in language
It keeps happening: women and mothers must also be erased from the vocabulary, at every level. They do not give up because the maternal symbolic is the most resistant obstacle to the transhuman project. We will not give up either. Forget it The General Medical Council -the public body that maintains the official register of doctors in the UK- has replaced the word 'mother' with neutral terms in its maternity guide for staff. The updated guide for employees who become pregnant omits [...]
Read now
11 September 2023
Female wombs in male bodies
The envious dream of all time -to be able to have children without women, to erase mothers, in short, the Grail- is getting closer and closer to being realised: in five to ten years' time, even biologically male trans people will be able to receive a womb transplant and conduct a gestation. An 'inclusive' wish-right that would improve their quality of life and alleviate the symptoms of dysphoria. While the lives and health of girls and boys born from these practices are of no concern to bioethicists
Euronews reports on the rapid progress of research on the uterus transplantation front, with particular reference to the request of trans MtF people whose bodies remain biologically male, while FtM people, if they retain their female genital apparatus, can undertake a pregnancy like any other woman: the 'pregnant fathers' that the mainstream press likes to report on are none other than women who self-identify as men. In the article, which we translate here, women are referred to as cis- women, suffixed [...]
Read now
7 September 2023
Appeal to the FDA: no more silence on puberty-blocking drugs
A petition asks the US drug agency -which has never authorised the off-label use of these substances for girls and boys with dysphoria- to counter the misinformation that propagates these treatments as effective and safe and to demand studies to prove it.Between 207 and 2021, the number of minors treated has more than doubled and the FDA can no longer pretend it is blind.
On his site Gender Clinic News Bernard Lane reports on an important petition to the FDA (Food and Drug Administration, US drug regulator) to take urgent action on the unapproved (off label) use of hormone suppressant drugs to block puberty in girls and boys who identify as transgender. Although this use has never been approved by the FDA, it is not possible for the agency to ignore the possible harm to minors who are subjected to these [...].
Read now
29 August 2023
Greece, womb and baby trafficking: babies 'kidnapped', couples stuck waiting
Team from the Mediterranean Fertility Institute in Crete arrested on suspicion of human and gamete trafficking, fraud and forgery. Many dozens of poor women from Eastern Europe persuaded to allow themselves to be exploited in order to supply children to mostly Australian principals
The Mediterranean Fertility Institute, a surrogacy clinic in Crete, was raided by the police on suspicion of human trafficking and fraud, and the entire medical team was arrested and taken to prison on charges of child trafficking. According to Greek police, a group of traffickers had co-opted 160 poor women -Ukrainian, Romanian, Moldavian, Albanian and Georgian- convincing them to provide egg cells and lend themselves as wombs for rent for a few tens of euros per month, housing them in [...]
Read now
15 August 2023
Denmark: no more hormones for children! Even trans people say so
After the UK, Sweden, Finland, Norway and the Netherlands also Denmark says stop to puberty blockers for gender non-conforming girls: those drugs are experimental and there is no scientific evidence that they work. But here the government initiative is supported by important LGBT associations: this is the first time it has happened. And in Italy? You cannot even know how many minors are treated
Denmark is also backtracking on puberty blockers for children confused about their sex: the Danish health system will henceforth offer psychological therapies and no longer drugs to adolescents who have not reported discomfort with their birth sex since childhood. This was announced by Health Minister Sophie Løhde during a parliamentary debate that rejected a proposal by the populist Nye Borgerlige (New Zealand) party to completely ban gender transition for minors.
Read now
9 August 2023
Spain: inmate pregnant with trans cellmate
The man -intact male body and no hormone therapy- had asked and obtained to be moved to the women's prison in Alicante because he 'self-perceived' to be a woman (self-id). A cellmate's pregnancy was the result. And the new Ley Trans, in force since December 2022, will make such transfers easier and more frequent
In the Alicante Cumplimiento Penitentiary Centre, known as Fontcalent Prison, an inmate identifying himself as a woman impregnated a cellmate. According to the account confirmed by several prison sources, the inmate had been serving a sentence in the male module of the prison for several years, but during his stay he started to identify himself as a woman. On his papers he continues to appear as a man and has never undergone hormone treatment, let alone surgery. [...]
Read now
1 2 3 ... 55