Spain reopens at the Ley Trans: sudden about-face by the PSOE
After having long blocked the law proposed by Podemos, and in particular free gender self-identification, the socialists are changing course. Perhaps following the recent electoral defeat in Madrid. On June 29, Pride time, the government will discuss the text fought by feminism. Which is very similar to the Zan bill

Share this article

Blocked since February, negotiations for Ley Trans in Spain suddenly resumed. Internal sources confirmed that the Government has unblocked the process for the law -which had stopped thanks to thePSOE abstention, ed. - which will predictably be brought to the Council of Ministers next June 29th, in full celebration of Pride. The great obstacle that the members of the Executive, Podemos and PSOE, had to face was the so-called free gender self-determination which it assumes is a person's will is sufficient to change their name and sex, without the need for medical reports or ongoing hormonal therapies as happens now. The consensual solution provides three months of administrative waiting from the moment of the request for modification, so that the person can ratify their decision.

For the Ministry of Equality, led by Irene Montero, which is negotiating and trying to pass this law, free gender self-determination was untouchable, as well as for the LGTBI and trans groups who were consulted and listened to during the debate. Free gender self-determination will be included in the law, as written by El Periodico and confirmed by EL PAÍS.

In the draft of the drawing Of law for the real and effective equality of trans people and for the guarantee of the rights of LGTBI people, to which EL PAÍS has had access and which may undergo modifications, it is stated that “qany person of Spanish nationality over the age of 16 can independently ask the Civil Registry to rectify the mention of sex registration. It is also said that "within a maximum period of three months"from his first appearance, the person in charge of the Civil Registry must summon the person to ratify his request, “affirming the persistence of his decision“. Once confirmed, the resolution will be issued "within a maximum of one month from the date of the second appearance”. Meaning what, the total time will come up to a maximum of four months. This administrative procedure convinced the first vice president of the government, Carmen Calvo (PSOE) which had been the most reticent with this rule, for which it asked for "legal certainty".

When the bill prepared by was made known in February Equality, Calvo publicly rejected that sex could be changed only by will and asked for "legal certainty" so that the text is not changed by the Constitutional Court, as hoped by Vox and PP who will certainly bring it to his attention. Behind the words of Calvo and Spanish socialism, the mobilization of the feminist movement which fears that the change could have irreparable consequences for the laws protecting women.

In the last week there have been many meetings and "at all levels" to unblock the situation. On Friday, Vice President Carmen Calvo, the Minister of Equality Irene Montero, and the Minister of Justice, Juan Carlos Campo, were seen. The meeting resulted in the commitment of bring the text to the Council of Ministers on 29 June, in time for the Pride celebration, and to continue negotiating. After that first step, the text will still have to pass the review of the consultative bodies and all parliamentary acts in the Cortes, with the contributions and amendments of the rest of the groups before its eventual approval as law.

There were also meetings with various trans and LGTBI groups, very active in negotiating the text. Representatives of State Federation of Lesbians, Gays, Trans and Bisexuals (FELGTB), of the association Chrysallis of families with trans minors and of the foundation Triangulo they went to La Moncloa on 7 June to present their proposals and try to unblock the negotiation. They were urgently summoned after they called a press conference on difficulties in implementing the law. Both these groups and Equality have proposed the three-month deadline for the Civil Registry and they rejected that a witness or third person is needed, as the PSOE proposed, to accredit the request to amend the register.

Differences between the governing partners led the socialist party to even vote against - with PP and Vox - the attempt to activate the 'trans law' in Congress , where minority groups have adopted it. It was May 18th. That day the Equality Minister called to speak to “apologize” to LGTBI groups and commit to recognizing “self-determination of gender identity” ahead of Pride.

 Il 16 giugno è intervenuta in una cerimonia la ministra per le Pari opportunità, Irene Montero.
The Minister for Equal Opportunities, Irene Montero.

The current draft merges the two laws that the Executive partners had agreed in their governance agreement, one on trans people and the other LGTBI, although the final text gives preponderance to the recognition of trans people as requested by both groups and by Equality. The details to close this common text are still missing, but what was the main difficulty from the beginning has been saved: free gender self-determination.

Currently, the person who wants to change their name and gender on the DNI must request a medical examination, start a hormonal process and obtain a psychiatric certificate, which lengthens the process by between two and three years according to the organizations' calculations. The text of the draft is in line with the proposal that the PSOE itself put forward to Congress and which was approved in the Chamber in 2019, as well as with the laws already approved in 13 autonomous communities, the last being the Canary Islands, which do not include cooling-off periods.

On minors and other pending issues

The draft presented in February by Equality also included the free gender self-determination for minors, another point that has raised doubts. The organizations had proposed splitting the change into three tranches. Children under the age of 12 could only request a name change, not gender, with the support of their families. From 12 to 16 years old, accompanied by family members or guardians, they could obtain a change in the registration of sex and name, and from 16 without any protection. The draft currently authorizes the change of registration of name and gender starting from the age of 14. Between the ages of 12 and 14 it can be done in court. If the parents do not agree, a legal defender will be appointed.

The age groups are one of the aspects on which we will continue to negotiate in the coming days before bringing the text to the Council of Ministers, to try to lower the limit to 12 years and to provide, as various regional laws already do, that trans minors can, at any age, change their name in schools to facilitate the transition. Issues related to access to or inclusion of healthcare for trans people are also being negotiated assisted reproductive treatments for lesbians, bisexuals and “people capable of having children”.

Other measures planned

The text of the law, whose objective is “develop and ensure“the rights of LGBTI people to ensure that in Spain”emotional, sexual and family diversity can be experienced in complete freedom”, according to the motivation, provides for further measures. These are some:

Protect the laws of equality. The draft expressly provides that with the change of registered sex the person will not be a retroactive beneficiary of the positive discrimination measures provided for by the Equality Law, approved in 2007. This registry adjustment also provides for not eliminating the "legal obligations" that the person previously had precedence, particularly those included in the Comprehensive Gender-Based Violence Act of 2004.

Ban on conversion therapies. These are practices intended to “change people's sexual orientation and identity or gender expression.” The draft bans them even when they have the consent of the interested party or his legal representatives. I am considered a “very serious” crime, punishable by fines of up to 150,000 euros.

Filiation of children born to unmarried women. In couples composed of a man and a woman, it is sufficient for the man to assume paternity to obtain filiation of a child. But in the case of a couple of unmarried women this is not allowed, and in order for the biological mother's partner to appear as the parent of the newborn, adoption must be carried out, which means a waiting period during which the second mother is not recognized , has no rights or no obligations towards the child, or the little one on her. The draft provides for the modification of article 120 of the civil code so that for non-marital filiation it allows that "at the time of registration of the birth" the "father or non-pregnant parent"make a compliant declaration"in the corresponding official form".

LGTBI diversity in education. The government, after consultation with the autonomous communities, according to the draft will include “contents relating to the treatment of sexual, emotional and family diversity of LGTBI people“ in programs for admission, access and training of teaching bodies. Furthermore, the Administrations “they will promote the introduction of positive LGTBI references in school materials, in a natural, respectful and transversal way, at all levels of study and according to subjects and ages“.

Infractions. The draft considers, among others serious infringements,”the introduction, promotion or tolerance of discriminatory working practices based on sexual orientation and identity, gender expression or sexual characteristics in companies that receive subsidies, bonuses or public aid". And among the most serious crimes, the use or dissemination of textbooks and materials in educational centersthat present people as superior or inferior in human dignity based on their sexual orientation and identity, gender expression or sexual characteristics”.

ON 26 JUNE, FEMINIST DEMONSTRATIONS WERE CALLED IN MANY CITIES IN SPAIN. IN THAT CIRCUMSTANCE, A MANIFESTO WILL BE SHARED, WHICH WE ANTICIPATE YOU HERE

FEMINIST MANIFESTO 26 JUNE 2021

IN SUPPORT OF THE FEMINIST AGENDA, AGAINST TRANS LAWS

Unfortunately, the regression in the protection of our rights as women is already an undeniable reality.

The offensive of the alliance between patriarchy and neoliberal capitalism against women in general, and against the feminist movement in particular, is leading us to a criminal situation both in our country and in the rest of the world, subverting all our demands and penetrating our entire legal system. Our analysis is clear: those who have claimed to be our allies and call themselves “the most feminist government in history” are transforming our laws, against the feminist agenda they have fought for the last 300 years.

With the complicit inertia of the head of government, the ministry for equality has ignored and despised the feminist movement, promoting anti-women legislation. Furthermore, regardless of political persuasion, regional parliaments are used as back doors to transform all laws under their jurisdiction, increasing the lack of legal protection and consolidating a regression in terms of violence, sexual and reproductive rights and material and symbolic discrimination against women in all areas, as well as the most basic rights of children and adolescents.

This has led the feminist movement to take to the streets today to demand from central and regional governments: COMPLETE REALIZATION OF THE FEMINIST AGENDA, STOP AND REPEAL THE “TRANS LAWS”. Yes, in the plural, “trans laws,” because they include all legislation that replaces the legal category of “sex” with “gender identity.” Added to this are the so-called Trans Law, LGTBI Law and Zerolo Law, about to be introduced in Parliament, which would criminalize people who, in the exercise of their fundamental right to freedom of expression, defend the use of the words woman, mother, vulva, or “make mistakes” in the use of pronouns, inflicting fines of up to 150,000 euros. Freedom of expression has already been curtailed in other places, such as Scotland, where two weeks ago we saw the arrest and trial of Marion Millar for simply posting a suffragette tape on Twitter. Of women suffragettes.

In this spirit, we call for the repeal of all or parts of the laws that threaten the rights of women and children, as well as fundamental rights and public liberties, such as the recently enacted Rhodes Act (on the protection of children against violence) and some provisions of the Celáa Law (on education), which generate confusion about the obligation to educate for EQUALITY, without distorting its meaning in terms of "diversity", as is already happening. We also ask for the repeal of the transnational regional legislation including, among others, 15 laws on "gender self-determination", 14 educational protocols and 15 health protocols which allow - even in the absence of a national law that recognizes the right to self-determination - sex determination, the implementation of sexist education policies, the violation of women's sex-based rights (allowing men access to our spaces and perverting statistics), and the indiscriminate hormonal treatment of children. And this is despite the fact that neighboring countries (such as the UK, Sweden and Finland) that passed these laws are now backtracking and banning the use of puberty blockers due to their irreversible and harmful side effects. Finally, we denounce the use of transnational legislation to allow rapists and murderers access to women's prisons; we are outraged and indignant about this.

Today we cannot fail to remember here the murder of Vanesa Santana in Fuerteventura, whose rapist and murderer, Jonathan Robaina, declared himself a woman on the first day of his trial (just three days after the unanimous approval of the Trans Law in the Canarian parliament) , which, if it had not been for the team of forensic experts who, in contravention of the regional legislation on the affirmation of "gender identity", denied the existence of gender dysphoria, would have ended once again with the transfer of a murderer of women in a women's prison under the protection of Instruction 7/2006 and Trans Law 3/2007, resulting in danger to the physical integrity of the inmates. Something the Equality Department and the rest of government denied ad nauseum was allowed under trans laws, “#ThisWouldNotHappen” they said, but it happened.

IN THIS SCENARIO, FACED WITH THE OFFENSIVE DIRECTED BY THE INSTITUTIONS AGAINST THE RIGHTS OF HALF OF THE POPULATION AND THE GOVERNMENT'S EVASIONS, THIS #26J THE FEMINIST MOVEMENT WILL FILL THE STREETS WITH DIGNITY TO BE DEMANDED PUBLICLY:

THE AMENDMENT AND EXTENSION OF THE LAW ON VIOLENCE AGAINST WOMEN WITH ALL THE PROTOCOLS, MEASURES AND ADEQUATE FUNDS TO FIGHT IT EFFECTIVELY #AgainstMaleTerrorism. #NonUnoPiù #NonUnoMeno #VoliNoiVivi #Against male violence #Against vicarious violence THE APPROVAL OF A LAW FOR THE ABOLITION OF PROSTITUTION WHICH PROHIBITS ANY SEXUAL ACCESS TO WOMEN THANKS TO MONEY: A LAW WORTHY OF A DEMOCRATIC AND NON-DEMOCRATIC SOCIETY A SIMULACRE OF PERSECUTION OF SEXUAL EXPLOITATION LIKE THE LAW ON TRAFFICKING WHICH WILL SOON BE DISCUSSED IN OUR PARLIAMENT. #AbolitionistLawNow #AgainstTheProstitutionalSystem #ProstitutionAbolition #PornographyAbolition #ProstitutionIsSlavery #NeitherSexNorWork #RapeIsNotFiction

THE REPEAL OF THE INSTRUCTION OF THE MINISTRY OF JUSTICE WHICH ALLOWS THE REGISTRATION OF CHILDREN BORN FROM THE REPRODUCTIVE EXPLOITATION OF POOR WOMEN OF OTHER COUNTRIES IN SPAIN. #STOPWombsForRent #STOPBabyTrafficking #STOPOvumTrafficking #WeAreNotVessels #NoToReproductiveExploitation

AND THE END OF THE TREATMENT OF "TRANS" LAWS WHICH ERASE WOMEN AND DESTROY OUR RIGHTS, THOSE OF CHILDREN, HOMOSEXUAL PEOPLE AND PEOPLE SUFFERING FROM GENDER DYSPHORIA, AS WELL AS THE REPEAL OF ALL THE ARTICLES INTRODUCING THE QUEER AGENDA IN OUR LEGAL SYSTEM. #NoTransLaw #NoGenderSelfID #SexIsNotGender #TransLawIsMisogyny #WomanIsNotAFeeling #NoToHormoneTherapyandMutilationofChildren #DontTouchChildren #StopCriminalFashions

Needs to which we cannot fail to add the DENOUNCEMENT OF THE PACT OF SILENCE WHICH PREVENTS THE CRITICAL VOICES OF FEMINISTS AND THE MULTITUDE OF EXPERTS FROM BEING HEARD IN THE PUBLIC MEDIA, IN FAVOR OF AN OFFENSIVE THAT DESTROYS OUR RIGHTS, WITH THE MEDIA COLLUSING WITH THE PROPAGANDA OF THE QUEER AGENDA FINANCED BY THE PHARMACEUTICAL AND ECONOMIC LOBBIES OF LARGE INTERNATIONAL CORPORATIONS.

Women, comrades, sisters, feminism is on the move and history has shown us that the fight is effective and essential. We recently had the opportunity to see this again when we learned of the Employment Appeal Tribunal's ruling in favor of Maya Forstater, a year and a half after she was fired from the Center for Global Development in the UK for tweeting and writing about the implications of sexual self-determination for women's rights.

THIS #26J THE FEMINIST MOVEMENT WILL RAISE ITS SECULAR VOICE TO STATE THAT: #WeWontBeSilence #WeWontBeErased #TheyShallNotPass

BECAUSE TOGETHER WE ARE INVINCIBLE AND WE WILL NOT STOP UNTIL WE ACHIEVE FREEDOM: LONG LIVE THE WOMEN'S STRUGGLE! LONG LIVE THE FEMINIST STRUGGLE!

here the article by EL PAÍS, translated by Marina Terragni


This article is produced through voluntary work.
Much of the news you read here you won't find in any other media.
If you think our work is useful, thank you if you can support us.
Even the smallest contribution is precious!

You can make a bank transfer to:
RadFem Italia Association
IBAN: IT59W0306909606100000402734

Share this article
Scroll to Top