California Rejects Law to Keep Rapists, Sexual Harassers Out of Women's Prisons
The proposal was from Republican Senator Shannon Grove and called for separate facilities for transgender women.

Share this article

On Tuesday, the Democratic-dominated California Senate Public Safety Committee Republican Senator Shannon Grove's bill to prevent transgender people convicted of sex crimes from being held in women's prisons was defeated, providing women with safety and privacy in spaces like showers and dormitories. The proposal responded to SB 132, sponsored by Senator Scott Wiener, which allows for the assignment of inmates based on gender identity.

Senator Shannon Grove

Grove, during the hearing, declared:

“I stand here today on behalf of women incarcerated in California prisons who are facing the unintended consequences of transgender people being housed in women’s correctional facilities.” She added: “Everyone agrees that we need to ensure the safety of female inmates and provide them with additional protections.”

The letter from the prisoner

Quoting a letter from a female prisoner, she highlighted the presence of men in a women's prison and asked: “Why does the state of California pay for condoms in women’s prisons?”

The only one to support the bill was Republican Senator Kelly Seyarto. Grove's proposal included separate facilities for transgender people, thus protecting female inmates, and barred access to males convicted of serious sexual crimes, such as rape or sexual assault. Grove criticized SB 132:

“SB 132 created a preference for transgender people. If you’re a woman in a women’s prison and a transgender person who has identified as transgender comes in and says, ‘I want to be with you,’ the woman in that cell has no recourse. She can’t say no because it’s considered discriminatory.”

Wiener called the proposal part of a “culture war” against transgender people, arguing that excluding males who identify as women is “dehumanizing” and that the reference to the sex offenders registry is “discriminatory”. Grove, on the other hand, accused the Democratic supermajority of having “a preference for predators over victims.”

Testimonies in favor included that of Amie Ichikawa, a former inmate, who asked the commission to demonstrate that “the protection of women’s safety is not up for discussion” and to prioritize “people over politics.” An inmate described being beaten by a transgender man, Tremaine Carroll, who caused her to have a “miscarriage.” Carroll is accused of raping other women in prison.

Department of Corrections data shows that 45 transgender men were transferred to women's prisons after SB 132, with 900 men requesting transfers to women's prisons versus 90 women in men's prisons. Many requests are being considered. According to 2022 statistics, 33.8% of trans-identified men seeking to transition are registered sex offenders and another 25.8% have been convicted of sex crimes. Erin Friday of Our Duty supported the proposal, criticizing Democrats: “The Democrats don't even want to release rapists and sex offenders from women's prisons. That's how much they hate women.”

Obama-era federal regulations prohibit assignment policies based on biological sex, but Trump has said he wants to change them. The bill’s defeat reflects the tensions between women’s safety and gender identity politics.

By Anna Perenna

source: Leif Le Mahie, Daily Wire


This article is produced through voluntary work.
Much of the news you read here you won't find in any other media.
If you think our work is useful, thank you if you can support us.
Even the smallest contribution is precious!

You can make a bank transfer to:
RadFem Italia Association
IBAN: IT59W0306909606100000402734

Share this article
Scroll to Top