Women-only spaces must no longer exist: Incredible Australian ruling Roxanne Tickle, a trans woman, sued Sall Grover, founder of the separatist network Giggle for Women, for not accepting her application to join. The Federal Court ruled in her favor: it is gender identity that matters, not sex. A ruling that also worries Reem Alsalem, a UN consultant on violence against women and girls. Grover intends to appeal
Sall Grover has lost her case against Roxanne Tickle, the trans woman who sued her for discrimination in 2022.
Grover, Australian, founder of Giggle for Women, a female only network based on sex, he had rightly Tickle's admission blocked after seeing his photo. Unfortunately the federal court ruled against her. Being banned from the app “for not looking woman enough” was considered grounds for indirect discrimination.
The case is very important because the sentence explicitly stated threw the concept of sex overboard in favor of gender identity.
For the judge, sex can be changed and if a man, in this case operated, has a special gender identity he cannot be discriminated against. Women, even those who don't believe in gender identity, have no choice but to bow. Grover was ordered to pay $10,000 in damages plus court costs to Tickle, who had sought $200.
Australia passed a amendment to the Sex Discrimination Act, the Sex Discrimination Amendment, which covers all forms of discrimination including those based on gender identity as well as sex and intersex conditions. No one paid attention at the time, but gender identity was the Trojan horse.
The amendment in turn is inspired by a UN convention that many countries in the world have signed, including Italy: the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women.
The judgment has robbed the app of its very purpose, a safe meeting space for women only. To add insult to injury, Tickle also demanded membership in the network.
Sall Grover, CEO of Giggle
Reem Alsalem, UN special rapporteur against violence against women and girls, was also very disappointed by the sentence. who commented that he was « seriously concerned by the dystopian ruling which distorts fundamental concepts such as sex and discrimination and at the same time evades international human rights obligations towards women. This decision, if not challenged, will constitute a dangerous precedent».
Alsalem recently announced that it intends to ask the UN to reintroduce sex tests to safeguard women's sports.
Reeem Alsalem, UN Special Rapporteur on Violence against Women and Girls
Grover, which was among the first to sign our petition to reintroduce the sex test in sport, commented "The sun will rise tomorrow and men will not yet be women." It is determined to appeal and needs help: Anyone wishing to donate is invited to do so on the page gigglecrowdfund.com
We hope that those who still believe that gender identity is a harmless concept will seriously reflect on what it entails in terms of erosion of women's spaces. Those spaces, whether they are a social network, a prison cell or an anti-violence center, they are no longer safe.
We're just getting started.
MARA ACCEPTURA
This article is produced through voluntary work.
Much of the news you read here you won't find in any other media.
If you think our work is useful, thank you if you can support us.
Even the smallest contribution is precious!
You can make a bank transfer to:
RadFem Italia Association
IBAN: IT59W0306909606100000402734
Share this article
Scroll to Top
We and selected third parties use cookies for technical and analytical purposes. Use the “OK” button to agree.